Savage needs to buy a scale or fire attorneys

I have an AR15 that weighs over 11 pounds. Add another few pounds when loaded. (That's Wyoming loaded, not Colorado loaded.) I built it heavy for shooting prairie dogs. Sometimes heavy is good.
Agreed! Weight is your friend when managing recoil with shotguns a smooth follow through vs a jerk stop/start or see-saw motion.
 
Who the hell is Randy Wakeman????

Google will tell you some. He wrote some articles for Chuck Hawks years ago. I read somewhere that he was originally a magician and tried to make a go at that but I guess it didn't bring home enough bacon so he got into being an internet firearms expert. Since it seems that everyone is an internet firearms expert these days, he specializes in muzzle loading expertise now. Which is probably good because there's not as much competition in that subject matter. This is all I know. From the little I've saw, he would be a decent resource for muzzleloader info. As far as his opinions of optics or long range hunting, there's probably about a good 100 or more members here that I would rate their expertise higher.
 
I am a long time savage fan and currently own 6 savage rifles. They are an innovative company so of course was not surprised to see them launch a line of straight pull rifles

All excitement ended when I saw the 22" barreled straight pull rifle weighing in at 11lbs. This follows the launch of the new Renegauge shotgun, that seems to have an innovative action, also weighs in over 10 lbs. I think randy wakeman referred to it as the worst shotgun he had reviewed in recent memory

Just don't see how such a strong engineering company can be so far out of step with competitive products or user preference. If it's the attorneys demanding that degree of robustness in an action driving the weight they need to retain new counsel

Anyone else feel similarly about these two new products? Ideally savage is processing the his feedback
Number one: does it shoot. Only accurate and precise rifles are interesting(semi quoting)
Don't take offense this is my observation: As Americans, we are very weight and recoil averse
I am a long time savage fan and currently own 6 savage rifles. They are an innovative company so of course was not surprised to see them launch a line of straight pull rifles

All excitement ended when I saw the 22" barreled straight pull rifle weighing in at 11lbs. This follows the launch of the new Renegauge shotgun, that seems to have an innovative action, also weighs in over 10 lbs. I think randy wakeman referred to it as the worst shotgun he had reviewed in recent memory

Just don't see how such a strong engineering company can be so far out of step with competitive products or user preference. If it's the attorneys demanding that degree of robustness in an action driving the weight they need to retain new counsel

Anyone else feel similarly about these two new products? Ideally savage is processing the his feedback
As an observation and please don't take offense to this it is just an observation among people I've hunted with.
As Americans we are weight and recoil averse. Much more so than our European cousins as well as the South Africans and Australians etc.
I personally believed this happened somewhere around the turn of the previous century. 1900's. Heck prior to that a 30 cal rifle was considered trash and a child's toy! Gov gave thousands to the Indians because it was considered less lethal! All perceptions of course. 30 cal rules the day here now. I'm sure a lot had to do with military engagements and doctrine over the last hundred or so years.

the reality is Americans seek these light and small bore rifles (and shotguns) for everything. The truth is the weight should IMO scale with a the cartridge. A good shooter should be able to pick up any gun and shoot well. But our EU cousins were Bred on big bore rifles and scatter guns. 375 being the smallest! Then of course the double rifles .400 to .600 all heavy guns with a lot of felt recoil. my partner just took an order for 6 600 Overkill bolt rifles for PH's in SA. It's an 11.5 gun with some serious thump and the guides plan to walk 10-20miles a day with it. It's really not that hard to walk with a 11lb vs a 8lb rifle. Be honest most of don't do that anyway. I've stalked with a Ruger PR in 6.5 CM with a NF ATACR on it for about a hours following pigs and blackbuck - yeah it was a heavy rifle but not unbearable. I appreciated that weight when it came time to pull the trigger too!
As Americans we also do another thing that is counter intuitive. We want this light and ultralight rifles to shoot 3-10 shot groups subMOA. That is not what they are made for. Shooting a 10 shot group in the same hole will take a heavy barreled/action gun. It's just physics and heat. Yes someone is going to tell me that their grandpas 30-06 shoots big holes all day. That's not science.
Those light guns are made for the cold bore one shot one kill scenario. It's not a competition gun so I don't treat it like one.

In the end shoot what you like and I sincerely hope you are successful with it.

consider the science behind all this, yes I'm a Bryan Litz fan and always a student of new information regarding our beloved sport and past time.
 
Ha Ha, I'll pass.
I'm not a mountain goat. The last elk I shot was in Northeast N.M. in a rancher's pasture. There were probably 60 elk out there migrating through. I walked 75-100 yards from my truck, picked out a good one to shoot, and rode on a tractor to retrieve it.

I've done the mountain hunt's in my younger years, but not anymore.
We can't all afford a private land hunt like some can. What did that elk cost you?
 
So your not surprised it weighs 11lbs?
Have you shot one? I bought one ASAP. It shoots like a dream. U just point it. That's all I do. Outside of being the best shooting shotgun I've ever owned, (even better than my old 1100 or V3 - which comes in close!), it is far & away the fastest shooter I've ever busted clay's with. I've let others shoot & they were all impressed. I picked out a petite little lady at the range & asked her to shoot it. Though it looks intimidating she tried it. Afterwards she stood there with her mouth agape, turned towards me in disbelief & exclaimed, "It doesn't kick ar all!" I bought one, LOVE IT & have never looked back. If you don't like it don't buy it!
 
Warning! This thread is more than 4 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.
Top