er shaw barrels question

Discussion in 'Rifles, Bullets, Barrels & Ballistics' started by harleybug, May 31, 2015.

  1. harleybug

    harleybug Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    196
    Joined:
    Oct 30, 2014
    Has anyone used these barrels before and how is the accuracy. Im looking at buying one but want some feedback. They are priced very well but its a little concerning. Im also looking at shilin i know they are night and day but this is my first build so i have no preference. Also does anyone hunt with a sendaro contour barrel, if so is the weight that bad or hardly noticable.
     
  2. lazylabs

    lazylabs Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    870
    Joined:
    Oct 26, 2006
    With the money spent on fitting and components for testing i wouldn't skimp on the barrel blank cost. It's not worth the worry of wondering if the barrel is the weak link.
     
  3. Lefty7mmstw

    Lefty7mmstw Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    4,431
    Joined:
    May 13, 2012
    if you are asking a 'smith to put his hands on your rifle and paying for it, you ought to be buying a rather good barrel. I'm a tightwad but I just bought a 28" 8" twist #5 7mm Shilen match grade ss blank to replace toe gun plumbed pipe that was on my 7stw. I wouldn't think of a lesser barrel unless it was me or a buddy (read: free labor) going at my rifle. Even then I'd balk.
    I've heard E.R. makes a decent pipe, but the $$ you have to throw at it makes any possibility of a bad or average shooter a no go for me.
     
  4. nkyshooter

    nkyshooter Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    131
    Joined:
    Sep 16, 2014
    I have an ER Shaw 6mmBR on my Savage 11 short action. It is an 8 twist 26" Savage Prefit that came threaded/chambered. I bought it new for $200.

    It shoots Berger 105 Hunting VLD's in the .2's all day and Hornady 75g VMax in the low .3's ... this is from an unmodified factory/bolt though I do have it in a relatively inexpensive Choate Ultimate Varmint stock ...

    Oh - I am am using Varget in Lapua cases with Remington BenchRest primers ... I get about 2850fps with the Bergers using a just below max load.

    Very cost effective setup and with the Bergers, I am confident to hit a milk jug to 1000 yards ...

    I like my ER Shaw even though some may not respect them as much as some more expensive names. All that being said, if I was going to pay a smith to chamber/thread/etc ... I'd probably move upmarket a little bit.

    Happy shooting!

    '
     
  5. MachV

    MachV Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,416
    Joined:
    May 31, 2001
    I own two Shaw barrels, a 6.5=284 sporter and a 7mag varmint.
    Spend the extra for an upgrade! The two Shaw's shoot and clean alright but appear to be not much better than the factory barrels they replaced.
     
  6. the jigger

    the jigger Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    63
    Joined:
    Jan 11, 2015
    I have two Shaws on Savage actions and have been satisfied and surprised by their performance. I have also used Shilen for a wildcat build. The greatest difference that I see is ease of cleaning. The Shilen seems to have fewer flaws in the bore. That being said, there is no appreciable difference in accuracy among the three barrels; all are sub-MOA. I would not hesitate to use Shaw again.
    GOOD LUCK and GOOD SHOOTING!!!
     
  7. J E Custom

    J E Custom Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    8,338
    Joined:
    Jul 29, 2004
    In My Opinion The ER Shaw barrels are on par with most factory barrels and even though the chance of getting a good one is better than a good factory barrel it is still not the quality that
    you can expect from the premium barrels.

    I have not personally seen what I call a good one, but that could be bad luck. I have a list of barrel makers that I wont build on and ER Shaw is one of them based on my experiences with them. I am
    glad that some have been satisfied with them.

    As said, After spending all the money to have a custom rifle built, don't scrimp on the barrel, It is the heart of an accurate rifle.

    Just an opinion

    J E CUSTOM
     
  8. dmj

    dmj Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    550
    Joined:
    Nov 16, 2013
    I have an ER Shaw rifle. One that they offer on their web site to build for you. They use a savage action. Guess I should clarify that I haven't been on their web site for several years so not sure what they offer at this time. My rifle is a 300 wm with 26 in. plus muzzle break. It's is mainly used as a hunting rifle and does shoot in the 1/2 moa range, if I do my part. I didn't order the rifle from them, as they would not commit to what kind of groups I could reasonable expect from the rifle. I purchased it on Gun Broker at approx 1/2 the price as it would have been from them and the rifle was new never fired. You can never own to many rifles and I guess at that price I was willing to take the chance. If I was building a rifle I would use a quality barrel, I wouldn't take a chance and they did leave me with the feeling that I would be taking a chance.
     
  9. sable tireur

    sable tireur Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    916
    Joined:
    Oct 8, 2010
    harleybug,

    As with all questions soliciting opinions about products, there will be a wide range in those opinions. Some shooters need or desire to have barrels which are known for a high degree of accuracy when chambered and attached to an action. For generic hunting type rifle they might be fine for some shooters. Some shooters don't have the necessity for that same degree and are satisfied with less. As some say, 'minute of deer' is acceptable for them.

    E.R. Shaw barrels are simply third tier barrels. This doesn't make them bad, they just aren't at the top of the heap for quality, accuracy and consistency. But for some that claim benchrest groups from these barrels, they have truly found that one needle in the haystack, a true rarity. Treasure that barrel since you won't find one again.

    Professional gunsmiths who grow their name and reputation by consistency of quality and accuracy will not, cannot take a chance on E.R. Shaw barrels. They have to go with the barrel makers who demonstrate those best qualities on every barrel and stand behind each one.

    Regards.
     
  10. Tabascoman79

    Tabascoman79 Member

    Messages:
    19
    Joined:
    Jun 2, 2015
    I've used 13 shaw barrels. From midway sales(not the best) to 3 rifles sent to them for clambering and fluting. 2 mausers that I had them do work on while installing a barrel. I've also had shilen and mcgregor. I won't use something other than a shaw. Seems to me most that have bad to say about them got them from midway or back in the 90s. I've been buying from them since 2007 and love the quality and their CS
     
  11. sable tireur

    sable tireur Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    916
    Joined:
    Oct 8, 2010
    As has been stated before, you are entitled to your opinions and beliefs regarding any product. Someone has to be supporting them since they are still in business. If their level of quality meets your needs, terrific! My guess is that thousands of average shooters/hunters use this product because of cost. If the barrels meets their needs, that's also great.

    He's the rub.

    Professional gunsmiths who build for clients that demand excellence cannot afford to use third tier barrel makers like E.R. Shaw. The clients won't stand for it because they will see the difference. They have the abilities to shoot high scores at long ranges and in tactical competitions, consistently. So Shaw barrels will never be on my client's rifles no matter when they were made.

    I use somewhere between 1,500 to 1,700 barrels a year, the vast majority being from Bartlein but a few from Kreiger, Brux, Gary Schneider, Proof Research, a couple from Hart and a couple from Lilja as supplied by some clients. After several years of these numbers, I've rejected exactly 3 barrels. Now that's a stand up record in anybody's book and it speaks volumes about the quality of the Bartlein barrels. Bartlein guarantees their barrels and we guarantee our work so using lesser quality barrels never enters into our thinking.

    If E.R. Shaw makes your day, that's as good as it gets. We aren't here to quibble about that.

    Regards.