Best "large" calibers for shorter barrels?

idcwby said:
Make sure your suppressor can handle the short barrel, some have a minimum barrel length depending on cartridge.

What distances are you wanting to kill elk at?
Click to expand...
Most of my hunting will be for deer sized game, but on elk I would say 700yd is probably my max distance I'd ever take a shot at confidently.

Also, the suppressor is a Harvester Evo.
 
OnCall605 said:
It is a SilencerCo Harvester Evo
Click to expand...
Same can I'm running on my 20" 30 nosler. This will be long, I load for quite a few shorter barrel long range guns.

As far as cartridge choice for a short barrel, decide the performance you want first. At a max of 700 on elk, and mostly deer, a .277 cal will work, though is on the low end, in my opinion. I built my rifle to be a 20", 1000+ capable elk rifle. For me, that meant propelling a 200-215 class high bc bullet 2900-3000 fps. So, I chose a 30 nosler. 208's at an easy 2940 with h1k

My cousin's wife's rifle I load for is a 19" 270 Sherman, essentially a highly improved .270 winchester. It shoots 140 badlands solids at 3060, and 170 Bergers at 2760. For comparison, their 25.5" rifle sends the 140's at 3240, and 170's at 2940.

I would, however, without a doubt go with a properly throated 300 wsm, on a mid length action (huge difference from SAAMI spec). You should be able to get in the 2750+ with a 200ish bullet without pushing things, there is great (adg) and good (norma) brass available, tons of bullet options, 300 wsm's are easy to get shooting well and stay in tune, there is tons of data available, and recoil won't be bad at all. My 9.5 lb 30 nosler is comfortable to shoot supressed, and a wsm will be better.

If 30 cal isn't your thing, then my only other consideration would be a 7 SAUM or 7 MAX (SAUM improved, can still shoot factory SAUM ammo). We have two 7 max's, both 20" tubes. My wife's 7 max is sending a 170 PVA Cayuga mono at 2835, with a conservative load of H1000. With N565, 180 Bergers will run about the same velocity. My father in laws 7 max is sending 180 hybrids at 2775 with n565, on a lower node, with a proof barrel that only has 25 rounds down it. I expect it to pick up 30-50 fps after fully broke in.

On a side note, if you go 30 cal, I would strongly suggest going with an 8 twist 4 or 5r groove.....mono bullets are improving quickly, and there will be some 180ish grain options from a certain manufacturer coming out that will have the bc around 210+ grain c&c bullets, and I have high hopes for terminal performance. I'm sure others will start to follow in suit as well. Badlands also currently has good options ranging from 175 up to 205. Jus sayin'.
 
codyadams said:
Same can I'm running on my 20" 30 nosler. This will be long, I load for quite a few shorter barrel long range guns.

As far as cartridge choice for a short barrel, decide the performance you want first. At a max of 700 on elk, and mostly deer, a .277 cal will work, though is on the low end, in my opinion. I built my rifle to be a 20", 1000+ capable elk rifle. For me, that meant propelling a 200-215 class high bc bullet 2900-3000 fps. So, I chose a 30 nosler. 208's at an easy 2940 with h1k

My cousin's wife's rifle I load for is a 19" 270 Sherman, essentially a highly improved .270 winchester. It shoots 140 badlands solids at 3060, and 170 Bergers at 2760. For comparison, their 25.5" rifle sends the 140's at 3240, and 170's at 2940.

I would, however, without a doubt go with a properly throated 300 wsm, on a mid length action (huge difference from SAAMI spec). You should be able to get in the 2750+ with a 200ish bullet without pushing things, there is great (adg) and good (norma) brass available, tons of bullet options, 300 wsm's are easy to get shooting well and stay in tune, there is tons of data available, and recoil won't be bad at all. My 9.5 lb 30 nosler is comfortable to shoot supressed, and a wsm will be better.

If 30 cal isn't your thing, then my only other consideration would be a 7 SAUM or 7 MAX (SAUM improved, can still shoot factory SAUM ammo). We have two 7 max's, both 20" tubes. My wife's 7 max is sending a 170 PVA Cayuga mono at 2835, with a conservative load of H1000. With N565, 180 Bergers will run about the same velocity. My father in laws 7 max is sending 180 hybrids at 2775 with n565, on a lower node, with a proof barrel that only has 25 rounds down it. I expect it to pick up 30-50 fps after fully broke in.

On a side note, if you go 30 cal, I would strongly suggest going with an 8 twist 4 or 5r groove.....mono bullets are improving quickly, and there will be some 180ish grain options from a certain manufacturer coming out that will have the bc around 210+ grain c&c bullets, and I have high hopes for terminal performance. I'm sure others will start to follow in suit as well. Badlands also currently has good options ranging from 175 up to 205. Jus sayin'.
Click to expand...
Thank you for taking the time to share your knowledge and experience. Here is a question, if I were to go with a factory rifle option such as a Fierce or something similar....knowing up front that the action length and twist will be somewhat of a limiting factor if looking at a .300 WSM, would you still recommend the .300 WSM or would you lean a different way? Fierce in particular offers it in a 9 twist and 20" barrel.

I do own a couple of custom rifles in larger calibers, but they have 24 and 26" barrels. I'm not sure that I'm ready to dish out the kind of money it'll take to start out with a short barrel custom this time around. Ideally, I'd like to keep the gun around $2,500 or under and putting some nice glass on it.
 
My primary hunting rifle is a 20" 270 sherman short. I am running the 150 ABLRs at 3075 fps. It has quickly become one of my favorite rifles I have owned. It took 2 elk this year at 535 and 608 yards. Both one shot into the lungs. I am shooting suppressed, and love the shorter barrel when I tack on an extra 6". My next rifle is probably going to be in the 338-375 range due to having a Silencerco Hybrid sitting in my safe begging to be put on something. No doubt it will have 18-20" barrel though.
 
jsmitt6 said:
My primary hunting rifle is a 20" 270 sherman short. I am running the 150 ABLRs at 3075 fps. It has quickly become one of my favorite rifles I have owned. It took 2 elk this year at 535 and 608 yards. Both one shot into the lungs. I am shooting suppressed, and love the shorter barrel when I tack on an extra 6". My next rifle is probably going to be in the 338-375 range due to having a Silencerco Hybrid sitting in my safe begging to be put on something. No doubt it will have 18-20" barrel though.
Click to expand...
I do have an un-shot Savage (HS-Precision Stock) .338 Lapua in the safe. Should I chop it off and buy another silencer?
 
jsmitt6 said:
My primary hunting rifle is a 20" 270 sherman short. I am running the 150 ABLRs at 3075 fps. It has quickly become one of my favorite rifles I have owned. It took 2 elk this year at 535 and 608 yards. Both one shot into the lungs. I am shooting suppressed, and love the shorter barrel when I tack on an extra 6". My next rifle is probably going to be in the 338-375 range due to having a Silencerco Hybrid sitting in my safe begging to be put on something. No doubt it will have 18-20" barrel though.
Click to expand...
Sound like those bullets opened up just fine and good accuracy for you.
 

Similar threads

B
  • Poll
Best long range calibers?
Replies
3
Views
1K
hawk45
H
K
Rebarrel or cut current barrel shorter
Replies
7
Views
1K
Gord0
G
R
Large caliber question
2
Replies
14
Views
4K
racerngr1
R
Orion2010
Best caliber for long range ?
2 3
Replies
31
Views
9K
barnesuser28
barnesuser28
H
Best short barreled 6.5 caliber??
6 7 8
Replies
103
Views
26K
Frank in the Laurels
Frank in the Laurels

Recent Posts

Top