I was wondering when this is going to surface.Can't be the brass, the muzzleloading folks have been shooting for centuries without it.
In your opinion: Most important cartridge component.
- Thread starter Calvin45
- Start date
Help Support Long Range Hunting Forum
MagnumManiac
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Feb 25, 2008
- Messages
- 5,588
I voted for the obvious choice...the BULLET.
This does all the work from rifle to target. If it doesn't do it's job, then it was a poor choice and the other ingredients used, apart from the brass, were wasted.
I can live with less than stella accuracy when hunting, heck, I can even live with using a less than stella powder, but I can't live with poor performing bullets on game.
I drank the Berger CoolAid, have regretted it more than half a dozen times now, like all bullet brands, some don't do what you think they will EVERYTIME.
My choice was poor.
Cheers.
This does all the work from rifle to target. If it doesn't do it's job, then it was a poor choice and the other ingredients used, apart from the brass, were wasted.
I can live with less than stella accuracy when hunting, heck, I can even live with using a less than stella powder, but I can't live with poor performing bullets on game.
I drank the Berger CoolAid, have regretted it more than half a dozen times now, like all bullet brands, some don't do what you think they will EVERYTIME.
My choice was poor.
Cheers.
Since a cartridge is a system, all of the components are necessary for it to function. That being the case, I tend to place priority and on the bullet, particularly for hunting where both accuracy and terminal performance are critical for success.
Rick Richard
Well-Known Member
All of them are important since they all work together. However, for "one hole" accuracy I have found case consistency within weight/volume within each other or batch to make the difference for me.
Calvin45
Well-Known Member
We'll call this concluded among us then
Seems the thing most people are particular about is bullet selection, powder and brass about tying for second, most people agreeing most any primer is fine.
some who voted for primer I think were doing so out of a place of needing them and not having them...that wasn't at all the question but it's all good
.
there were the inevitable "they're all important" responses, but again, all good, knew that was gonna happen.
until we talk again in another unimportant and provocative poll thread....
Cheers, thanks for the debate!
Seems the thing most people are particular about is bullet selection, powder and brass about tying for second, most people agreeing most any primer is fine.
some who voted for primer I think were doing so out of a place of needing them and not having them...that wasn't at all the question but it's all good
. there were the inevitable "they're all important" responses, but again, all good, knew that was gonna happen.
until we talk again in another unimportant and provocative poll thread....
Cheers, thanks for the debate!
