Brownells + Surgeon Action = Rusty parts

NomadPilot

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Messages
524
Location
GA
I wanted to relay an experience I'm in the middle of in case it helps anyone else make a more informed decision.

I'm in the process of acquiring parts for a rifle build. I don't know caliber, stock, etc yet, but I knew I wanted to use a Surgeon action. Brownells had the best price on them and I've had great service from Brownells before, so I ordered one. It arrived at my FFL a few days later - so far so good. I looked it over quickly, filled out the form and took it back home and started opening it up fully. What I found made me sick to my stomach.

The bolt knob was speckled in surface rust as well as this part of the bolt plug:



Everything else was fine, luckily, especially the serial numbered part. I called Brownells who said I could return it for a full refund. Well great, but I want the action and I don't want to deal with shipping again and another FFL transfer, etc. I asked them to replace just the rusty parts, but they don't stock Surgeon parts. They said to call Surgeon directly. I was annoyed that they couldn't make it right, but I called Surgeon anyway.

I talked to Steven who said they've had five actions sold by Brownells showing up with rust. He said Brownells opens the packages to inspect them, then doesn't repackage them properly to prevent rusting in storage. He said to send it to them and they'd fix it. I don't know if they'll polish or just replace the parts. I think it'd be easier for them just to replace them.

So... Surgeon will make it right, and I'll still come out ahead financially, but it won't be without some pain in the process. I'm not sure if what I saved is worth it or not.
 
Last edited:

msalm

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 18, 2007
Messages
234
Location
SW Wisconsin
There's no finish on those parts, and in the process of building a rifle those parts will be bead-blasted and finished. I have a couple Surgeon actions at home in the bags, and they will RUST IN A HEARTBEAT. I wouldn't be too bent out of shape about it. Build the rifle, bead blast all parts, and ceracoat or duracoat the action and whatever else you want finished and be done with it.
 

bigbuck

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 20, 2009
Messages
1,650
I can understand your frustration . Not to hijack but do you know what a surgeon long action would cost for an edge?

Bigbuck
 

NomadPilot

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2009
Messages
524
Location
GA
There's no finish on those parts, and in the process of building a rifle those parts will be bead-blasted and finished. I have a couple Surgeon actions at home in the bags, and they will RUST IN A HEARTBEAT.
I understand the lack of coating - that's why I sprayed Eezox on the parts when I got them. That should keep them in good shape until I can decide on the rest of the build. I at least wanted to start with parts in good shape.

do you know what a surgeon long action would cost for an edge?
I don't - I'm guessing $1600+, but I think the XL model comes with bottom metal and mag, which makes the price not that much more than the short action repeater. Single shots are of course a little less.
 

grit

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 23, 2005
Messages
1,375
Location
Utah
Fretful, yes. But no damage done. The blasting and finish will take care of it.
 

Coyboy

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2005
Messages
2,132
Location
OK
I can understand your frustration . Not to hijack but do you know what a surgeon long action would cost for an edge?

Bigbuck
A Surgeon RLR will work great for an edge and retails for $816.
It's their remmy clone with one pc bolt m-16 extractor and pinned lug.
 

Fiftydriver

Official LRH Sponsor
Joined
Jun 12, 2004
Messages
7,097
Location
Fort Shaw, Montana
I have ordered two XL receivers directly from Surgeon and both had parts that had some surface rust on them and they were all in sealed packages.....

None of the rusting was severe and when bead blasted, you could not even tell where it had been so nothing more they very minor surface rust with no penetration into the steel in any way.

I think your seeing something that is much more common then many would expect. My only question, why does surgeon use chrome moly receivers and ship them in the white. Stainless would be much better all around, no rust, no NEED to finish or coat if not wanted either.
 

jasonprox700

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 17, 2007
Messages
261
Location
Black River Falls, WI
Here's my take on this subject. I work for a company who produces exhaust parts for the heavy truck, construction, and ag industries (completely unrelated, so bare with me). A lot of the parts we make are mild steel parts, that without a good oil coating, WILL rust within a few hours (less than an hour during the summer). We deal with rusty parts daily. If the parts are to be blasted or polished (mechanically or chemically), the parts ship. A very small amount of the surface will be removed anyway, so it doesn't matter. Surface rust is simply that, surface rust. If you are receiving parts that are rusty, sure, you have every right to be disgusted. I would be too. But for the hassle involved in returning and exchanging the parts, I would probably just submerse the parts in oil (WD40 or something similar) over night. Take some fine steel wool and lightly polish the effected surfaces. You would be surprised at how easily it comes off. If the parts are to be blasted, I wouldn't worry about it.

If it were me, I would be ****ed too. The product should leave their doors with a rust preventative and sealed in a plastic bag. You spend a lot of money for those parts and you expect a certain degree of quality. I'm not excusing the rust, but it is an easy fix. You need to weigh how badly you want the part right now, and how much hassle it will be to exchange the parts. In the end, it is your decision. Good luck with what ever you choose.

BTW,
Post some picks of your build! I am thinking about using a Surgeon for a .338 LM AI someday.
 

Trending threads

Nightforce has great tracking capabilities, they are rugged, a bunch of elevation, holds zero forever, and reticles are designed for long range shooting. So if you are looking to shoot long distances constantly, then you need a scope that can take the abuse. -- gilmillan1


Culture Of Excellence At Nightforce Optics
By Len Backus

A high level of quality both in production and in service. Read More


Nightforce is such a solid combo of reticle, available elevation, glass that is good enough to shoot at the longest range you can dial. Nightforce has bullet proof construction that can handle the incidental horse rolling or some other rodeo action. -- bigngreen


Nightforce ATACR Scope Review
By Jeff Brozovich

The new NightForce ATACR is for sure a top choice for any long range shooter. Read More


The total package. Nightforce is the best I have used as far as turret feel and solid detents. I have never had one that didn't track right on and always return to zero. Nightforce NXS is the best value for everything I need. -- Broz


Nightforce Velocity 1000 Reticle Review
By Scott Shreve

I think Nightforce knocked it outta the park with this reticle! Read More

NightForce


Top