Ill be headed out in just a couple hours to go load my dogs and try to kill a deer. Only a dog hunter would work 12 hours then leave work to go run dogs until dark the next day just to try and kill a deer. As for running dogs with tracking collars and shock collars yes I do but Ive never had a deer go where I want it to because I use a shock collar to shock my dog in the direction I want him to go, the dog is going to follow the scent of the deer.............. Only people that have ever run dogs will understand the mentality of why we do it, when the dogs are coming straight at you the deer they are running has horn until you actually see it and sometimes it does have horns.
I have to agree on some levels that it is not a great management tool for trophy deer, but that is also up to the local G&F department to enforce the regulations on horn size.
I have personally talked to G&F biologists that say on privately owned hunting leases that allow dog hunting the age structure of the deer is older than on still hunt leases owned by the same company, where the moto is if its brown its down. You dont always kill every buck you run with the dogs hell sometimes you never even see the deer.
Ill take my dog hunting over still hunting any day as long as there is a place to do it. I have over 600,000 acres of National Forest within 10 minutes of me that will be my stomping grounds for a long time to come.
If I ever caught some SOB killing my dogs there would be more than court costs and fines coming his way, I would probably even have a court date myself when everything was said and done.