Quick scope question

hillhunt

Member
Joined
Nov 24, 2015
Messages
9
Which has more influence on collecting light in low light conditions (dawn and dusk), the size of the scope (40mm or 50mm) or the size of the tube, 30mm vs 1 in tube. Will a 40 mm w a 30 mm tube collect as much light as a 50 mm with a 1 inch tube. Just pondering the question.
 
Both... The bigger objective gathers more ambient light, and the bigger tube has larger lenses in it, which transfers more light. So the bigger the tube and the bigger the objective, usually the brighter and clearer the image will appear, because the image you see in your scope, is nothing more than reflected light.

Another advantage to a larger tube, is more reticle adjustment, so that is also something to consider when purchasing a scope. If you plan on dialing and shooting long range, a 30mm tube is usually the starting point.
 
Mudd, I've read countless times the tube has no bearing on amount of light transmission, just windage & elevation. Correct or not I don't know, but I have read it again and again.
The bigger the objective(front lens nearest the muzzle) the more light collected. How much light making it to your eye depends on the power magnification of the scope(and the glass quality, assuming the same for comparison purposes).
The amount of light coming out of the scope is "exit pupil"
EP = objective divided by magnification power

50mm objective at 10x = 5.0mm exit pupil

40mm objective at 10x = 4.0mm exit pupil

A 50mm objective will give 25% more light than a 40mm, given all else equal in the scopes. That's my understanding anyway.
 
Obj lense size of the same quality bigger will transmit more light and provide better res because of that extra amount of transmission.
Obviously a top end 40mm will have better color fidelity contrast edge to edge sharpness etc etc than a entry level glass.
 
Which has more influence on collecting light in low light conditions (dawn and dusk), the size of the scope (40mm or 50mm) or the size of the tube, 30mm vs 1 in tube. Will a 40 mm w a 30 mm tube collect as much light as a 50 mm with a 1 inch tube. Just pondering the question.
The objective diameter is what limits light gathering. The tube diameter limits vertical and horizontal adjustment.

Nearly all high quality scopes are going to have close to 99% light transmission so in low light it's all about the objective diameter and coatings.
 
Both... The bigger objective gathers more ambient light, and the bigger tube has larger lenses in it, which transfers more light. So the bigger the tube and the bigger the objective, usually the brighter and clearer the image will appear, because the image you see in your scope, is nothing more than reflected light.

Another advantage to a larger tube, is more reticle adjustment, so that is also something to consider when purchasing a scope. If you plan on dialing and shooting long range, a 30mm tube is usually the starting point.
Light is at it's brightest when focused tightly. Think about when you were a kid playing with a magnifying glass in the sun.
 
Different grinds on the lenses can direct the light, too, regardless of lens diameter.
Grinding won't increase the surface are by any significant amount. The grinding has more to do with clarity and focus.

A given diameter objective can only collect and transmit so much light even if you had glass capable of 100% light transmission (which of course doesn't exist).
 
Grinding won't increase the surface are by any significant amount. The grinding has more to do with clarity and focus.

A given diameter objective can only collect and transmit so much light even if you had glass capable of 100% light transmission (which of course doesn't exist).

If you grind in a deep convex (central thickness), then yes, it will increase surface area, but like you said, not by an significant amount. And polishing has to do with clarity and focus. :D
 
If you grind in a deep convex (central thickness), then yes, it will increase surface area, but like you said, not by an significant amount. And polishing has to do with clarity and focus. :D
Concave and Convex both increase surface area by only a very small percentage.

Polishing is part of the grinding process. You polish by using ever finer abrasives.
 
Which has more influence on collecting light in low light conditions (dawn and dusk), the size of the scope (40mm or 50mm) or the size of the tube, 30mm vs 1 in tube. Will a 40 mm w a 30 mm tube collect as much light as a 50 mm with a 1 inch tube. Just pondering the question.


Scopes cannot collect light.
 
Yes I realize that now after reading up on it some. They can only transmit light, right?
 
Last edited:
Yes I realize that now after reading up on it some. They can only transmit light, right?
No, that is incorrect.

On Riflescopes

The 4 Best Low Light Scopes

Rifle Scopes Reviews By Expert Hunters - 2015

http://www.shootingtimes.com/optics/optics_leaupoldvx_l_040706/

The objective gathers, concentrates, and transmits light.

The diameter of the objective limits how much light can be gathered and concentrated.

The quality of the glass, grinding, and coatings determine how much of that light will be transmitted.

This is true whether you are talking about a rifle scope, spotting scope, telescope, or magnifying glass.

A scope is not like a window. A window does one thing, it transmits light.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 8 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.
Top