Suggesting a shoe is hard to do.. cadence, foot strike, foot roll, heel-to-toe drop, need for cushion, etc. etc. all come into play. Trying to find a shoe that matches a person's barefoot foot strike is generally considered best because it works with the body, rather than causing it to conform to something that isn't natural.
All that said….I've run thousands of miles in ASICS but then they switched some minor things up in the 21XX series and I had nothing but issues. I switched to Mizuno Wave Riders and again ran thousands of miles. They worked well, but I could never get the life out of them.
Then.. I found "On". I've run thousands of miles in these shoes (On Cloudsurfer is my standard shoe, CloudFlow is for days I'm looking to go faster, and CloudVenture Peaks are my trail running/racing shoe). I LOVE them. They provide enough support, have enough cushion, solid traction, they last (occasionally exceeding 500 miles / pair pending how I rotate them and the weather they've been through), and so much more. I've trail raced in the Peaks many times in distances up to and including 100 miles. For me, ON fits like a perfect glove. Works with me, not against me.
I tried to love Altra on trails and just couldn't find the love. I dig the zero drop, but hated the toe box. I felt I was running on a slip-n-slide all the time!
I'm also saying all of this from a strictly running perspective. While I've turned quite a few friends on to ON for their day-to-day life's (hospital workers on their feet all day as an example), I know they aren't for everyone.
Other thing to ask.. what do you do in the gym? I also suggest if hiking with a pack to prep for a hunt to make sure your hunting boots are on your feet for a lot of those hikes (not necessarily all, but most!).