I had the rifle checked by two separate gunsmiths, one was able to close the bolt on the 280 Rem (Standard) no-go gauge and he estimated it had an excess headspace of .008" and the other was able to close the bolt on a 280 Rem go gauge with a piece of tape on the back and felt it was within spec.
The other issue that we have is that he purchased the new 280AI SAAMI/ dies, which if you follow the directions in the box will set the shoulder back an additional .014". This left us with a headspace of .017"- .022"
Since the owner of the gun is new to reloading and has the new SAAMI dies already, we are setting the barrel back 1 turn and having it rechambered to the new 280AI SAAMI/ Nosler design. This hopefully will eliminate all of the issues. We will be using new a brand new reamer and gauges.
Thanks for all the help.
First; Two different gunsmiths should not have gotten two different head space clearances.
The chamber did not change from one to the other.
The "New" 280 AI should be .012 to .014 Thousandths shorter than the original 280 AI, which should not allow a standard 280 rem head space gauge to close in the "New" 280 AI.
Tape on the back of a head space gauge is not a good way to measure head space (It can be compressed and give false readings) brass or stainless shim stock is the only way to accurately
measure head space.
SO- If you can close the bolt on a 280 Remington head space gauge (Do not force it) you have the original 280 AI chamber and can shoot all 280 ammo EXCEPT the new Nosler ammo.
If You have the "New" chamber, you should not be able to close the bolt using the 280 Head space gauge(The standard 280 head space gauge is used to set head space for the OLD 280 AI so standard 280 ammo can be fired safely while fire forming to the AI chamber).
You can jam the 280 or 280 AI into the "NEW" AI chamber most of the time but sizing the brass
to fit the new chamber is recommended.
If you have the "NEW" AI chamber you should only shoot Nosler Ammo in it.
If you have the old AI chamber you can shoot all ammo except the Nosler safely.(Shooting the Nosler ammo in a Original AI Chamber can lead to case splitting because of excessive head space.
So you must know what chamber you have.
The "NEW" AI dies can be used in ether chamber if set correctly after fire forming.
Hope this helps, And as Shortgrass said: Just because a person has barreled a couple of actions this
does not automatically make them a gun smith.
Proper head space is paramount for safety and accuracy, so it should be measured correctly and precisely.
J E CUSTOM