Primers

Winchester (WLR) primers are the hottest non-magnum primers according to M.L. McPherson.

The only way to know is to test.
 
I have Winchester, CCI and Federal all in large rifle magnum. Don't ask because I removed all the guns, silver and gold bullion from the safe and replaced them with my primers. The only "real" difference that I found was that the Winchester primers seemed to have hard anvils and sometimes I would get a fail to fire from them. I don't know it is just this batch or something that is characteristic with Winchester primers. As for difference in performance I have not experienced any difference. I did read in one of the replies that if your load is at maximum or even close to it I would recommend dropping the load and working up to it slowly.
 
CCI is all I use. I returned almost 1000 Winchester primers to them for a refund cause four of them blew out along the edge making deep marks in my bolt face. Do a search and you'll find others have had same problem with them. Won't use em anymore.

Dave
 
I have Winchester, CCI and Federal all in large rifle magnum. Don't ask because I removed all the guns, silver and gold bullion from the safe and replaced them with my primers. The only "real" difference that I found was that the Winchester primers seemed to have hard anvils and sometimes I would get a fail to fire from them. I don't know it is just this batch or something that is characteristic with Winchester primers. As for difference in performance I have not experienced any difference. I did read in one of the replies that if your load is at maximum or even close to it I would recommend dropping the load and working up to it slowly.
I have been reloading both pistol and rifle ammunition since 1970 and have used about any and all variations of cases, primers, powder as well as bullets. Very seldom have I ever loaded to the maximum load for any caliber. I have found out over the years that seldom is a max load the most accurate. Best accuracy seems to come slightly below the max and that varies dependent upon the cartridge and powder used. Throughout the years I have not noticed a discernible difference in any load in any caliber with only a primer change. Most loads seem to work with just about any good primer. Magnum primers do not make any difference when used in non magnum loads however when loading magnum loads magnum primers are necessary to ensure proper ignition of the larger powder charges used. As for brands, I use Federal, CCI, Winchester and Remington interchangeably with only very slight variations in group placement or size. As to primer reliability, the only primers I have ever had issues with were CCI Large Rifle many years ago when 5 rounds out of 20 loaded failed to fire, even when attempting to fire them with a second firing pin hit. Hearing a click when one pulls the trigger on a nice Buck is disheartening at best. I swore off CCI primers for many years because of it. I have never experienced any blowouts or misfires with Winchester or Federal primers, An occasional misfire with Remington small pistol but nothing really of consequence other than an alibi when shooting over the National Match Course.
 
And I've found just opposite about primers.
I can directly affect a load's results with primer changes, primer seated crush changes, and pin striking changes, all while every primer still goes bang.
This with cartridges at/below 260AI capacities.
 
Back
Top