Sometimes I think we over-think things.
I agree, except IMO it's more under-thinking of things, before over-acting.
It seems often that folks take wrong actions, merely for the sake of 'consistency',, only to cause inconsistencies.
And they don't know it.
The only sizing we will ever do to actually make brass consistent -is fire forming.
Your brass is never more consistent than as pulled smoking from a chamber.
So any downsizing we do after that, necessary or not, a lot or a little, degrades consistency.
A way to manage this is to use custom sizing dies, fitted from YOUR fully fire formed cases (the best standard).
New brass is very inconsistent, and downsizing of it only serves to amplify this condition.
When you downsize, you roll brass thickness, hardening it here & there. You can think of it as adding energy, or adding character.
When you downsize inconsistently, because the brass you're sizing is inconsistent, you amplify different character in each case.
You have no way to remove the abstract energies that you just added, except to anneal. But you can't anneal away as much as you added with FL sizing.
So if FL sizing is in your plan, then your objective should be to add all that energy consistently across your batch of brass.
That occurs only with fully fire formed cases.
If you FL size before or during fire forming, then you will never reach stable dimensions. Your brass will endure perpetual change for as long as it lasts.
I realize this matters not to most folks. But with a question of whether you should size before fire forming, I say you should not, unless you have to. And it won't hurt anything to wait a bit on big sizing, until it's needed.
There is an approach that includes pre-work hardening of web areas, where that's the only way to make brass last. Cool plan, but I would use a custom ring die for that. Not a FL die.