308 subsonic hunting bullet

Anyone with experience with a good bullet for hunting whitetail. Ours are small so needs a bullet that expands quickly and the lower velocity. Any recommendations? I have been looking but all seem to be sold out except for faster twist 300 blackout. It will be a 308 win with 1:10 twist 26" barrel. I finally picked up some tin star powder it is supposed to be the next best thing to trailboss but it is unobtainable now

Thanks

Buck
I've loaded up some 190 grain Hornady X-bullets, heard good things about them but have not put them through anything yet. supposed to expand @ 800-900 fps.

Shot a cardboard box @100 yrd, with oak tree back up. was impressed that after hitting the box it apparently open up to leave quarter size hole in trunk of tree. Hand loads approx 1200 fps muzzle vel
 
Last edited:
I've shot and harvested at least 3 deer with a subsonic 308. I was using 210 Bergers at around 975 FPS at under 50 yards. No bullets exited the deer and were usually found near the offside skin. All deer expired within about a minute. I stopped hunting with the 308 because to me it just didn't have enough energy to complete the job efficiently. Since the rifle was suppressed it made little to no noise and the deer never seemed to realize they were shot. They were feeding and would just look up and then go back to feeding after being hit. Within 30 seconds to a minute they would wobble and eventually fall over within a few yards of where they were hit. If they would have decided to run they could have covered a lot of ground before they expired. When shooting subsonic, velocity is a constant so the only way to increase energy is to increase mass. I did buy some 240 grain Sierra's but never had time to work up a load. I since went to a suppressed 458 socom or 45-70 with 500 grain bullets and all deer shot expired within seconds…..larger hole with an exit wound seemed to get the job done.
 
I've taken 7 white tail deer with Lehigh 197GR ME Bullets loaded to 950fps... solid performance on each one.

Shot out of 10.5" barrel h110 powder 300 blackout.

If you can find some trailboss you can do it out of a .308. Or .30-06. Ive done it with 208 amaxs in the past. Just will take some tweaking.
I just got some Lehigh ME's to try in my 300 BLK. The reviews seem very promising. Here's a link to a YouTube guy who tests both Hornady and Lehigh.
 
I have taken 5 whitey does with 308 subs. All were with 220 Matchkings in a 10 twist with Trailboss. None went more than 25 yards and all were recovered readily, though not all had bleeding wounds. All shots were less than 30 yards from a ground blind.

Study up on what the WW1 Brits figured out about tumbling bullets. More or less, find the distance limit of stability of your bullet, and stay within that. The long bullet in a slow-ish twist will upset its nice flight shape and tumble at the slightest hint of interference, such as grass, branches, hair, ribs, meat, etc. The 220 acted like a two blade broadhead does; I was surprised and impressed.

Don't expect any bullet to expand as we think of bullet expansion. Sufficient velocity provides the forces necessary to overcome the strength and thickness of the metals in your bullet. You can weaken things manually, such as mentioned above with drilling hollow points, or you can do it by design, as in a hollow point cast bullet. Then you can fiddle with your cast bullet alloy, or not alloy and shoot pure lead. At 1000fps, a pure lead 308 bullet will certainly mushroom, but you are still limited in energy delivery by the kinetic energy available to impart. So, you are back to the broadhead theory: cut as deep as inertia will take you and make the proper impact.

I have also shot 7 bison, all 1100 pound heifers, with subsonic 308. These were 147 ball and Trailboss. All head shots. Properly placed, these little bullets are effective at stopping brain function. Shot into sinus, they just create problems, sometimes taking several hits to connect with brain or brainstem. Bison in a group do not respond calmly to one of their own bleeding from the face, nor does the rancher who will be the one repairing fences and trying to collect his investment.

One must be on his game using less than sufficient projectiles, as an archer would need to be with field points on big game.
 
None available currently but you can backorder them:

I shoot the 200s in 300 BLK - they're designed to open slow, and these two are in your twist range. Hornady 190gn Sub-Xs are ok, you can also use the 160gn FTX for the 30-30. Some people have been pulling the polymer tips from Hornady bullets (especially in the big 458s) to get better expansion. If you did that I would drill the cavity more open.

My opinion (I'll only give it once, promise) is that you're beating a square peg into a round hole, centering mainly around a 26" 10 twist barrel isn't right for this. The 308 can be made to work but the twist is going to hurt you a lot by limiting your bullet weight/length. No way you're going to get there with a 200+gn mono, which are the ones that expand the best in my experience.

If you want to do this though (I'll support it, I'm crazy when it comes to subs), start high, work slower, make sure you don't stick a bullet in the barrel, and make sure bullets are stabilizing before you launch your can downrange.

One issue you'll be working against is the extra case capacity of the 308 relative to the very small capacity of the 300 BLK (I use that a comparison because it's a versatile 30 cal sub). Bullet weight isn't just about retained energy, it's also about being able to use a larger charge weight yet stay slower and because bigger bullets take up more space, both working to maximize your load density. Seat as deep as you can, this isn't the place to seat all snuggly with the lands. You can try to edge up into 180-200gn bullets if they're cup and core, preferably flat base, but shoot enough without the can on to be sure you won't get a baffle strike. This is a big reason I have a Hybrid 46 from SiCo - the larger holes in the baffles give a lot more margin for error when I'm doing sketchy things.

This link is an interesting read where he goes over using pistol powders in the 308 specifically - those powders might be easier to come by than the cowboy powders.
I have NOT tried his shtick about magnum primers and drilling that flash holes on the cases out, I won't vouch for that all nor recommend it until you've loaded a lot of subs. I use magnum primers, but drilling out the flash holes seems like a poor solution to the problem of trying a different powder. Natchez has H110 in stock now, Precision Reloading has IMR 4227, and it seems like pistol and shotgun powders pop up pretty frequently.

Looks like the general wisdom on Tin Star is start at 12.0gn and work down from there. I'd be curious to know what the full case capacity of TS is - fill up an entire case with the powder and weigh it, and see how 70% of that compares to 12gn.

One last thing to leave you with - don't assume velocity will fall in a linear manner, it can drop off very suddenly.... I recorded a 190gn Hornady Sub-X going 614 FPS from a 300 BLK rifle while working down. You'd better believe I checked the bore even after hearing the bullet skip off the ground and hit the backstop. The load dropped from the edge of supersonic to 614 FPS in just over a grain of powder - a 10% load reduction cut velocity by half. This wasn't a poorly charged case - I was intentionally working down ladders with several powders, and that one went south very fast.
Very good advice (But what do I know) 🤔🤷🏻‍♂️
 
So, you are back to the broadhead theory: cut as deep as inertia will take you and make the proper impact.
It's a good theory - and it absolutely woks, too. That's where the monos like Leigh and Makers excel, with the way they peel open but the petals remain attached they function very similar to mechanical broadheads. On light skinned animals should open up completely in the vitals and cut through. The problem is the density of the metal means the bullet is lighter than a lead equivalent, which exacerbates the bullet length/barrel twist stability issue.

I'll also admit I didn't think about cast bullets, this might be a good application for them with the barrel twist he's using because of how they can be shaped.


More or less, find the distance limit of stability of your bullet, and stay within that. The long bullet in a slow-ish twist will upset its nice flight shape and tumble at the slightest hint of interference, such as grass, branches, hair, ribs, meat, etc.
My concern with stability isn't so much upon impact, it's primarily inside the bore of the suppressor. It doesn't take much to yaw the bullet through a baffle - be that from bullet instability, thread concentricity/ shoulder squareness, or baffle design - especially if you're using a suppressor that matches the caliber.

Cup and core or lead bullets will do better because they're generally shorter at any given weight than a mono. Suppressors with larger bores have a larger margin for error. Some baffle/core designs are more symmetrical than others User serviceable baffles can be put in wrong. Direct thread has fewer tolerances to stack up than QD mounts. Lot's to consider. The bare minimum is shine a light down the barrel and make sure the suppressor isn't visibly out of alignment. I'm worrying because in his case it's a marginal twist, if it was a 7 I wouldn't be concerned.

Cardinal rule of loading subonsics - work down... without the can. At least at first, you don't have to take it off for every tweak to a load forever - but if it's a new combo, be smart and take it off.
 
It takes something major as the bullet leaves the barrel for it to yaw enough to hit baffles in a concentric-mounted can. Ive never seen it, but that doesnt mean it cant happen with proper mounting.
 
For the best results use purpose built sub sonic mono projectiles from the likes of Lehigh, they make a few different types in various calibres


Certainly not cheap but they do work, rather than conventional projectiles that are designed for super sonic use that will pencil through or tumble unless they meet heavy resistance giving extremely inconsistent results

Your twist rate may limit you, but with your barrel length, trail boss & a decent suppressor it would be very quiet
 
Thanks guys this is all good thought provoking information. Definitely a concern on suppressor, as I will be testing above and below my load once found. To be sure environment or pressure changes from tilted guns etc does not create a potential for baffle strike

Thanks

Buck
 
Thanks guys this is all good thought provoking information. Definitely a concern on suppressor, as I will be testing above and below my load once found. To be sure environment or pressure changes from tilted guns etc does not create a potential for baffle strike

Thanks

Buck
This may have been covered previously, start fast then slow down (opposite to conventional supersonic load development), don't use the suppressor until a stable load at 100 yards is found

1040-1080 fps is the "ideal" sub velocity,

Sight in for 75 yards, it will be slightly high (1-1.5") at 25 & 50 then 4-6" low at 100

I have use subs on & off for years, first 308 then 300Blk & 450 Bushmaster, soon 350 legend hopefully

I much prefer the 450BM with 220 Lehighs, impressive performance
 

that bullet was designed purely for subsonic use.


if you use anything but trail boss or a similar bulky powder, be sure to stuff a cotton ball down in to the case to keep the powder from moving when it's turned horizontal.
 
It takes something major as the bullet leaves the barrel for it to yaw enough to hit baffles in a concentric-mounted can. Ive never seen it, but that doesnt mean it cant happen with proper mounting.
I think the leading cause of baffle strikes are crush washers on ARs, they're just flat not the correct part to use to install something that needs to be aligned, but people keep doing it.

Followed by loosening while shooting, an unsquare shoulder or the threads being cut wrong, then any of the tolerance stacking assembly errors that comes from incorrectly using QDs, muzzle devices, or threaded parts of serviceable cans. All my bolt actions are either direct thread or the large shoulder TBAC 338 mount because it's simple and has fewer parts involved.

Legitimate baffle strikes from stability should be rare. In his case it's low probability, but marginal setups bear a little more scrutiny.

Thanks guys this is all good thought provoking information. Definitely a concern on suppressor, as I will be testing above and below my load once found. To be sure environment or pressure changes from tilted guns etc does not create a potential for baffle strike

Thanks

Buck
That's why I was testing down so slow, to see what happened and avoid an oops. I'm about to work up a subsonic 308 load for a 20" 10 twist, I'm starting with TB and 190 Sub-Xs.
 
Top