could use help deciding between 2 used nikons for first longer range scope

[GermanGuy]

Hello everyone,
i am having trouble deciding between 2 used scopes at a pawnshop..
they have a

Nikon- MONARCH 5-20-44SF MATTE BDC (BRA13202) for $285 and a

Nikon Prostaff 7 3-12x42 for $300

the rifle it is going on will a Savage fcp sr 308 20"

the reason why its between those 2 is while buying ammo i looked throu there used scope section and the Monarch got my interest, quick online search and price seemd good at first so its on layaway then i saw the box that looked old and found out it is a discontinued model and i dont know if it still keeps up with newer $300 scopes ...

its really clear and sharp but when i was about to leave i noticed the prostaff 7 which seems to be similar or better from 5-12 power as in i see more then just what i aim at it seemed bigger on same power setting , newer, 30mm tube but it stops on 12 vs 20 .

my use for now is 100-300y target shooting but i want to be able to try 600 or more if i ever get there without the need of a new scope rightaway

thank you for your time

 

[ShtrRdy]

If you're going to be doing target shooting then go with the higher magnification. If you think you'll be doing some hunting then the lower magnification would be nice.

 

[FEENIX]

If you're going to be doing target shooting then go with the higher magnification. If you think you'll be doing some hunting then the lower magnification would be nice.

Ditto!

 

[Rich Coyle]

Where can you get a Monarch 5-20X44 for $285?!

I put one on a Kimber 84 .308 for deer hunting this years. Plenty good for the woods where I hunt and lots for checking out a deer on the other side of a canyon to verify whether I wanted to shoot it or not. So I guess that tells you I would go for the 5-20X.

 

[Dosh]

Guy, I just bought a used Monarch 5X20X44 for a steal at $150 and appears sharp/clear. It is a discontinued model that was upgraded to their "ED" model and much higher price. Noticed what was the economy model, the Prostaff seems to be getting more promotion from Nikon lately. I will use this scope to test trading rifles and loads. If it doesn't hold zero I can send it to Nikon for free repair or replacement. For you, my choice is whichever scope looks better to you. Good luck

 

[GermanGuy]

thanks for the responses. so i take it that 285 is an ok price for the monarch?!
i am almost leaning towards the prostaff7 but they are asking new price for a used scope so im just hoping the monarch will be a good deal .

thanks again

 

[Rich Coyle]

$285 is a great price if the scope is like new.