• You must be a Supporting Member to create a listing in the Long Range Hunting Marketplace. To read all the rules, click here.

    We offer multiple options to become a Supporting Member here.

Is Hornady brass any good.

Coldfinger

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2020
Messages
1,959
Location
Hills&Hollers
I just began loading a lot of 6creedmoor brass for the second time. All the primers seem pretty loose even tho I had no pressure signs on the first firing. I just test fired a load and no spot around primer all looked fine. The primers just seemed pretty loose to seat using a lee load all primer seater. I have the same issue with 22 creedmoor hornady brass. I try to use Norma but was unavailable when barrels arrived. Only time I've had loose fitting primers was due to obvious pressure! Just odd it's with hornady primers, any ideas or like experiences?
 
Relative question but: Yes.

I have never had a problem with Hornady brass...however, you will probably get a lot of answers to the contrary.
 
Last edited:
no problems here with hornady, i have used hornady brass in 300 win, 6.5 creedmoor, 308, 7 rem mag. all good here with no complaints.

ive found the primer pockets dont last more then 8-9 loads for me. however, i dont anneal, so by then i just start off fresh with another lot of brass. its so cheap i could care less.
 
Relative question but: Yes.

I have never had a problem with Hornady brass...however, you will probably get a lot of answers to the contrary.
This is the only Hornady brass I've ever used. I've used Win, Norma,Rem, Nosler and Norma just never had this issue. Should of listed using CCI primers BR2
 
I have had so many problems with hornady brass,dies ,bullets and ammo I avoid all their stuff like the plague .There big bore brass like 405 win and 416 rem mag is total junk .Their customer service is terrible too .I quit using hornady anything and never went back !
 
I have their brass in 416 Ruger. Have had zero issues after many reloads.

I have several Hornady die sets, only Forster makes a better bullet seater.

I have two LnL presses and I have broken parts on them due to my own carelessness. A phone call to Hornady in the US, and they shipped me the spares at no cost.
 
Last edited:
I am using Hornady brass loading 6.5x284, 264 win mag, 300 win mag & 7mm STW never had an issue with not 1 piece yet, out of several 100! For me at least seems like CCI mag primers are a little snug, at times?? On the rare occasion I have had a problem Hornady customer service has been great! I have lost small parts to trimmer, stuck case remover, etc & a simple call gets the part I need usually at no cost at all, they even send with free shipping!
 
I am using Hornady brass loading 6.5x284, 264 win mag, 300 win mag & 7mm STW never had an issue with not 1 piece yet, out of several 100! For me at least seems like CCI mag primers are a little snug, at times?? On the rare occasion I have had a problem Hornady customer service has been great! I have lost small parts to trimmer, stuck case remover, etc & a simple call gets the part I need usually at no cost at all, they even send with free shipping!
I'll just chock it up to my starting loads being a tad on the pressure side, I usually see the signs on primers first but that's all I can figure. I did hit pressure on a ladder test but tossed the brass for that! The loose pockets fired fine so I'll keep an eye on them. Just the first Hornady brass I've used except .460&500
 
@Coldfinger just loaded up some fresh 300 RUM RP brass for my edge, Remington headstamp….the loosest pockets I've ever encountered with new brass......DANG! first firing shows smoke on case head. great, $200 down the toilet. oh well - bad luck I guess? I have had great luck with RP in the past with the ultra's.

I think sometimes regardless of brand we just get a bad batch.
 
I reload large volumes of 204R for prairie dog shooting. I think I have used every brand of brass available. Hornady brass has been good to me. I have noticed a couple things in my experience. Hornady brass is slightly thicker reducing the powder capacity ever so slightly.
I think Hornady brass is a little softer. Softer is good for necks and shoulders but maybe not so good for primer pockets. Casual observation from a bunch of experience but certainly not a scientific study.
 
... was due to obvious pressure ...

There is a common mis-perception that pressure signs are obvious. They are not.

There are different indications of pressure, none of them can be measured by eye.

By the time you see the physical manifestation of pressure, you are already damaging the hardware and components. Bolt setback. Stretched web area. Brass stuck to the chamber walls.

Measure everything, or it's heresay. If you think the primer pockets are loose, measure them, and compare to new brass. That's the only way to figure out if the pocket loosened up, or if it was a factory defect to begin with. How the seating feels is not a measure of primer pocket size.

A lot of reloaders quote the physical indicators, such as popped primers or a stuck bolt, to describe their pressure or lack thereof. Looking at the primers after firing tells you if the primer cup was harder or softer. A soft primer will spread itself flatter than a hard primer. Neither is a pressure measurement. Saying that you see no pressure signs is like saying you can't see any gamma radiation from the surface of the sun.

For my rifles, with the primers I use, I see no difference in fired primers when working up a load from the low to high end of the velocity range.

Use a chrony when doing load development, and learn to correctly use the velocity number in the loading manual. The first rule of load development is to ignore any load data that is not verifiable in a powder manual.

I've seen a lot of loose primer pockets, and so far it's never a factory defect, it's always from chasing velocity numbers.

So for the OP, if after two firings you really do have loose primer pockets, my money is not on the brass, it's on too much velocity.
 
Not a primer pocket issue, but I had 50 pieces of 30-06 brass I had used with 165 gamechanger behind 59 grains of imr 4350 and after the second firing I would said 36 all showed sings of cracking bear the bottom of the case. Really has me thinking of going away from their brass.
 
I started using Hornady brass in 6.5 CM out.of necessity. I developed an excellent load, and because the ESs, and accuracy have been so.good (sub 3/8 moa), I have not switched to anything else, in that caliber. I accumulated around 175 pieces, so even with shooting often, I only have 4 or 5 reloads on them. At this point, I have had a lot.of fun and at very little expense. This brass owes me nothing. Once it's done, I do have Lapua waiting to be used.
 
I use Hornady bullets, dies, presses and brass all with good results. I would especially say this related to their bullets and dies. Their dies are giving me some very good results by measured numbers.

My only brass is 458 Lott. I'm getting close to 2300fps....I'm only on my second firing, but they seem good. I'm measuring case head expansion and it is good.
 

Recent Posts

Top