You are comparing apples and oranges. That dont work.
Both have high reliability and are good dollar values.
You either favor the 1911 grip angle which will draw you towards the XD or the Luger grip angle which will take you to the Glock. One or the other will compliment you.
You have to...
2 nice set ups! I like the springfield with the lyman rear sight the best.
Im a big fan of micrometer irons myself and run a redfield micrometer rear sight with hunter style knobs set up on my Win 70 30-06.