Elk rifle

Discussion in 'Elk Hunting' started by arthurj, Dec 8, 2010.

  1. arthurj

    arthurj Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    460
    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2005
    Hey guys,
    I have never hunted elk but I want to in the next few years and I may build another rifle with that in mind. What are your thoughts on why a .338 with 2000 lbs of energy kills better than a 7mm with 2000lbs of energy? Does it? I hate recoil and don't really like brakes. I can deal with a 7mm unbraked. I've had a 300 rum with a brake(sold it), and the recoil was like a 243 but it made me dizzy to shoot it and the blast was tremendous.

    I guess the larger frontal area of the 338 would transfer more energy, but assuming a good bullet in both of them that will penetrate fully, can a 338 make that much larger of a wound channel? I have been reading lots about this for a while and I kind of agree with the guys that say a marginal hit with a 338 is no better than a marginal hit with a 7. And that with a well placed 7mm they should go down just as fast.
     
  2. silvertip-co

    silvertip-co Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,131
    Joined:
    Jun 20, 2007
    either is a great choice, I use 7mm Rem Mag myself. Anything bigger than a 243 will work( I say that because hundreds of elk are killed every yr by young people using .243 rifles ). Dont overanalyze and miss elk hunting.
     

  3. Don Ward

    Don Ward Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    120
    Joined:
    Jul 25, 2009
    In my experience, poor placement results in more lost elk than bullet or cartridge choice does. Once you decide what is enough gun to kill elk with decent placement at the ranges you want to reach, anything that limits that proper placement starts increasing your odds of losing an elk.

    Recoil is certainly a factor in shooting well. How big a factor differs individually. For me, big calibers in a hunting weight rifle are no fun to shoot without a brake and I don't like brakes because too often myself or someone I'm with skips getting ears on when hunting. Also, you have to be very aware of where you are set-up if you are trying to spot for someone who is shooting with a brake to be effective at keeping glass on the target.

    Seeing hundreds of elk taken with all sorts of cartidges, bullets, and placement, at ranges from 5 feet to 1100 yards, combined with what I can shoot good and the ranges I need effectiveness at, would make the 7 mag my choice out of those two.
     
  4. meatyrem

    meatyrem Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    604
    Joined:
    Sep 3, 2010
    Aurthurj. Like you said with a marginal hit one marginal hit is not gonna be any different than another marginal hit. Shot placement is critical. As for cartridges, you can't go wrong with either, both are excellent for elk. Choose the one you would be most comfortable with. I believe the 7mm rem mag was developed for elk hunting. I personally would go with the flatter shooting round myself. Also flatter shooting means less hold over. And I've always been partial to the 7mms, as I own a 7rum. You just can't beat a premium 160gr at 3000fps. Flat enough for open country and hits hard enough for anything that walks within the fifty states. Or you can step it up to one of the bigger 7mms, a little more recoil than a rem mag. If you choose a 7mm it can be in a lighter rifle too without punishing you as much as a 338. Either way though, they won't know what hit them..............................................................meatyrem.
     
  5. meatyrem

    meatyrem Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    604
    Joined:
    Sep 3, 2010
    If I could only own one rifle for elk/deer; it would be hands down a 7mm.
     
  6. arthurj

    arthurj Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    460
    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2005
    Thanks everyone,
    That is exactly what I wanted to hear. I know the way the 300 rum treated me was not fun. I think the blast from the brake gave me more of a flinch than the 50lbs of recoil without it would have. I am going to do either a 7rem mag or dakota I think.
     
  7. meatyrem

    meatyrem Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    604
    Joined:
    Sep 3, 2010
    Arthurj, either one of those would be a fine round for elk. With a little more of an egde with the Dakota round. My only concern about the Dakota is availability of ammo. Unless that is if you roll your own. Then I don't see that as problem. Me, I wouldnt have the first clue Of where to find dakota ammo, nor have I even seen a Dakota rifle. I hear they are nice. Myself, I have 7rum and if I want to load it up I can, if I want to load it down, I can. If I remember correctly, Remington developed the the 7 rem mag for the purpose of elk hunting. And, if you load your own you can step it up a bit with the rem mag and have more than enough gun for elk and moose too. I would say the 7rem mag, just for the simple thought of it would just be all around cheaper in the long run. I hope that can be of some help, meatyrem.
     
  8. bigngreen

    bigngreen Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    5,816
    Joined:
    Nov 24, 2008
    Just curious, what kinda brake did you have on the 300RUM? I dislike recoil so I kinda like brakes or light cals, one day I'll be able to move up to a suppressor, best of both worlds!
     
  9. arthurj

    arthurj Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    460
    Joined:
    Jan 29, 2005
    bigngreen,
    It was a holland. It really felt like a 243, but the blast was horrible. If I shot it without double ear protection I got a little woozy. Maybe I'm a wimp though. It was like a howitzer going off in your face.
     
  10. kc

    kc Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    970
    Joined:
    Jan 7, 2003
    I have a 7mmMag this was the best purchase I ever made. If I can see it I know I can kill it.
    Its real rough on Deer but Caribou, Moose, Elk and Bear, this is the calibre.
     
  11. Long Time Long Ranger

    Long Time Long Ranger Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    2,612
    Joined:
    Mar 12, 2002
    Anytime you go up in caliber you have a better killer on large big game. That is why they have caliber minimums in Africa. Larger calibers stop big game quicker. If you are just looking for an elk rifle then neck the 7mm rem mag to 338 and you have a 338 win mag. It is a noticably better elk rifle than a 7mm. Shoot a 185 Barnes ttsx in it and the recoil is not bad at all. The 225 accubond also does a very good job in the 338 win mag.

    If you are concerned about recoil and want a 7mm I would do a 280 AI, 7mm Gibbs, 7mm JRS or something like that off a blown out '06 or 280 case. They will do anything a 7mm rem mag will do with less recoil and noise. The 7mm STW is a better round than the 7mm rem mag with much better performance but then more recoil you said you didn't like. I have quite a few 7mm's in standard and wildcat cartridges and shot elk beyond 1000 yards with them back in the 70's. But then I found the larger calibers are much more effective on large big game. Basically if you put a large caliber huge chunk of lead quality big game bullet anywhere in the torso of an elk you will probably get your elk. Even with a marginal shot that elk is going to be a sick sob and lay down close by for a finishing shot. With a 7mm or small caliber you had better hit him in the right spot or he can go for miles and be bear food. That is the difference I have seen in about 35 years of elk hunting and continuing to look for a better elk rifle.

    If you are buying an elk rifle then get an elk rifle and not something marginal that can be used on elk. In over 40 years of hunting I have never been overgunned. But I have been in many situations where I wish I had more gun.
     
  12. meatyrem

    meatyrem Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    604
    Joined:
    Sep 3, 2010
    Arthurj, I'm convinced you answered your own question in your first post. :) then the second two post's back it up too.:)
     
  13. cross

    cross Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    258
    Joined:
    May 30, 2007
    I can't tell any difference between a 7mm magnum and a 338WM on elk. My experience has been that both will deliver about 25% bang-flops.
     
  14. specweldtom

    specweldtom Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,064
    Joined:
    Jun 7, 2004
    .340 Wby and 250gr Nosler Partition. Elk poison. On the bench, shoot it in a Caldwell lead sled. On the hunt, when you take the shot, you won't feel the recoil at all.

    See my signature

    Just my opinion, Tom
     
    Last edited: Dec 15, 2010