Winchesters vs kimber

[Travis1971]

Trying to figure what I want for xmas theses are the 2 rifle models I'm looking at in 338 win. I have never owned either in these models so any advice would be appreciated. There is only $60 in msrp.

Kimber America | Montana | Model 8400 Magnum | Rifles

Model 70 Extreme Weather SS -- Winchester Repeating Arms -- Product Item Detail, ITEM 535206236, UPC 048702002670

 

[Jim in Cali]

That's a tuff call right there.

 

[MudRunner2005]

If I were interested in either one of those rifles, I would probably go for the Kimber over the Winchester for accuracy. But I like the looks of the Winchester better (I'm a sucker for stainless with a fluted barrel). But I feel like the Kimber probably has a better shot at being a more accurate rifle, than the larger mass-produced Winchester.

 

[g0rd0]

They both look awsome, I think that I would go for the Winchester The fluteing and that extra 8 onces is my tipping point

 

[Rick Richard]

I owned a Kimber in 308 and it was fairly accurate with hand loads. The only reservation I would have in the caliber you are considering is the weight or lack of in the kimber. The 308 gave a bit of a kick. I can't imagine what that would be in 338.

 

[CogburnR]

Wow, ouch. Way light for a 338WM. Recoil would be more than I would want to tolerate.

Both are nice, I have a Kimber 8400 Classic I really like,have Winchester FTW's I like. I hunt with the Kimber way more, it fits me better and the action is smoother. I'd probably get the Kimber. I really like the crf and 3 position safeties both have!!!

 

[Travis1971]

I know these rifles are light but my options are limited to 1) I want a CRF 2) I want stainless steel 3) I have no intent to make this a daily shooter 4) wanted to stay in this price range or less, 5) this was an option Ruger® Guide Gun Model 47117 but 20 inch barrel on a 338 win??? or this if it could be found Ruger M77 Hawkeye Sporter Rifle .338 WinMag 24in 3rd Stainless Laminate Black
I would consider other options if it meet 1,2,3,4 ????

 

[Tikka 300wsm]

Out of those two id choose the winny so i wouldnt worry about scratching the wood but id also consider this Montana Rifle Company » XWR – EXTREME WEATHER RIFLE

 

[Methow Packer]

Wow, ouch. Way light for a 338WM. Recoil would be more than I would want to tolerate.

Both are nice, I have a Kimber 8400 Classic I really like,have Winchester FTW's I like. I hunt with the Kimber way more, it fits me better and the action is smoother. I'd probably get the Kimber. I really like the crf and 3 position safeties both have!!!

I agree. I too have both. I had my Kimber 300WM rebarrelled using a Brux fluted stainless 26" r. Not because the light sporter barrel wasn't accurate but that it heated up so fast when bench shooting. Typical of any sporter rifle. I really like their quality workmanship. Good bedding and smooth action. Good size mag box. The rifle shoots consistent .5 inch groups. very pleased