VH,
Some of my customers feel this donut will result in inconsistant gas flow through the case neck. THey are more technical then I am but I do see some use in removing this donut.
This is mainly with wildcats that need to be necked down from what I have seen. I also do not like to have a two diameter neck if you will because they seem to work harden faster for some reason.
Also, in a tight or min neck chamber, if a donut is present it can grow in thickness with the more firing on the case. On the initial firing things may have plenty of bullet release, onthe secon and third and fourth, you may get a situation where the case neck can not fully release the bullet and pressures will change as a result and your POI will also shift slightly.
In factory chambers or looser fit necks, this probably makes no difference at all but in my tight necks I have seen this.
In fact the first time I noticed it was with my 6mm-284. I turn my necks to 0.0015" under chamber neck diameter on a loaded round and after a couple firings, you could not slip a bullet throught the mouth of a fired case. It woudl slide freely intil it hit the donut and then could not be pushed down any more.
I started reaming along with turning at the same time and this took care of the problem.
Yes if you use a mandrel properly, it will push most of the donut thickness to the outside of the neck where the turning cutter can clean it off but it also lifts the portion of the neck ahead of the donut up as well which will result in an inconsistant neck thickness comparing the neck thickness from the mouth to the neck/shoulder junction. IT will be slightly thinned just ahead of where the donut was.
This occurs to a higher degree with cases that have been fired a few times and are work hardened a bit but when turned as virgin brass this is not a huge deal but it does happen.
As a machinist I know that when you move material out of position from one location, it often take some degree of the material around it to a different location as well.
I just prefer to remove it where it is originally so that no other material will be displaced in the expanding process/
maybe a silly theory but it has worked for me so far.
Good Shooting!!!
Kirby Allen(50)