Which ammo would you use?

Based on my experience both the Ballistic Tip and Silvertip will work great. They are great deer bullets and will drop the animal in its tracks with good shot placement.

Stay safe and good luck on the hunt
They are actually the same bullet. Silvertip just has an added thin coating
 
I use the deer xp in the creed for a loaner. I've recovered 2 gut shot deer in less than 100yds and 5 others closer than 10 steps from impact with chest shots 1 frontal 2 should bone and 2 high shoulder shots.
 
Top