Just out of curiosity how close were you seating the Berger to the lands 0n the ai? Im sure the barrel will last much longer in the ai
I'll have to check when I get home. I'm not seeming to recall that off the top of my head, like some of my others.
Velocity will determine how well the rifling in the barrel lasts, which means, if they're the same velocity, they should have about the same barrel life with all things being equal....HOWEVER, the .257 Wby holds about 10-15gr more powder, which means a bigger blast, and a longer flame in the bore, which means it will torch the throat faster than the .25-06 AI will, so the .25-06 AI barrel should last a little bit longer in theory, but barrel life is something I don't like to go around quoting because it's got so many factors that play into it, that it's virtually an unknown. It could last 500 shots if you get it really hot and continue to shoot it, or it could last 2,500 shots if you only shoot it a few times a year and don't ever really let the barrel get hot. You just never know.
There is something called "The Point of Diminishing Returns", and what that is referring to, is when a case gets too big for a particular caliber bullet. Basically meaning that the extra efforts and extra powder capacities and shorter barrel life, are not worth the very small gain in velocity you will get. IMO, the .25-06 AI is the largest case the .25 caliber bullets can fully utilize, and any case larger than that (.257 Wby or larger), and you are burning 10-15gr more powder (or more) to only gain about 50-75 fps, but all that extra powder burns the throat longer causing heat cracking, which can lead to accuracy issues. So it comes down to this... Do you want shorter barrel life and greater powder consumption for only 50-75 fps increase in velocity? If so, then go for the .257 Wby. If you want to get the most efficiency out of your .25 caliber's case design, and only be about 50-75 fps slower than the .257 Wby, then go for the .25-06 AI.
I promise you this...Whatever you're shooting won't notice that missing 50-75 fps.