You sir have to be one of the stupid people I have ever communicated with. Black and white let me explain what black and white means. First off it's slang for obvious. When someone tell you " I shipped it out Monday" and they didn't that's a "obvious" or black and white lie. He was signed in because his profile page tells what time he was last on the site, so he had multiple changes to pm me back. I also see you are from Wyoming probably one of his friends so it's nice of you to stick up for him.