280 or 30-06 for Elk

midgetorama32

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2009
Messages
61
I'm looking to rebarrel a model 700. Looking to have a nice lightweight elk gun that could potentially take elk out to 600 yards or so.

Does one of these have any huge advantages over the other? With the 280 I was thinking of lighter recoil with higher BC buillets but the 30-06 has ammo available everywhere and possibly more knockdown power? I will be handloading and am considering the 168gr 7mm and 185 gr 308 VLD's.

Thanks for any thoughts.
 
Do you want to reload etc. If not I'd keep it simple and of the two choices you mentioned I'd go with the old stand by 30-06...availability and choices are endless.
 
Just for random comparison. Midway 280AI one choice 52 bucks for 20, 30-06 about 80 choices 14-91 bucks for box of 20 with many excellent choices for around 35 bucks.
 
I'm looking to rebarrel a model 700. Looking to have a nice lightweight elk gun that could potentially take elk out to 600 yards or so.

Does one of these have any huge advantages over the other? With the 280 I was thinking of lighter recoil with higher BC buillets but the 30-06 has ammo available everywhere and possibly more knockdown power? I will be handloading and am considering the 168gr 7mm and 185 gr 308 VLD's.

Thanks for any thoughts.

I've never taken an elk with VLD bullet so cann't help you there. I own afew elk rifles and the calibers you mention I also own but I don't consider them as "potentially take elk out to 600 yards or so." I want alittle more rifle if it was me I have bolt face open build a 30 cal mag rifle or 7Mag.

I know this day and age we all want one rifle to fit all types of hunting. My first bull elk here in Co used a 7mag with 154gr Hornady bullet that was mid 70's that was the year we moved here. I later rebarrel that rifle to a 30-338mag.

Since you already have the rifle did you hunt elk with it before or what caliber are you using now?
 
They're both fine cartridges. Take your pick, then put a good bullet where it counts. With elk, be prepared to send another before they make it to a 2,000' dropoff into a nasty canyon. Anchor 'em!
 
Good for you Tom!
I can honestly say, I personally, have never taken anything at 600 yards in my life nor anyone in my family or group of friends. It's extremely rear to shoot over 100 yards at anything in Colorado let alone 600 yards. Elk in Colorado are seldom seen vulnerable, where legal. It is however possible to shoot from one mountain to another, but who wants to carry out a one thousand pound animal. Even so, I'm sure there some who need the validation for their choices. I'm sure I would find this too to be an overkill, but the more inexperienced hunters might disagree where using the Barrett .50 caliber to reach out over a mile, but I don't see its legitimacy for Colorado game. I'm just happy that my dentist doesn't use dynamite for repairing teeth. And yet, there are those who need to be validated for their choice of calibers, when logic prescribes otherwise. I'll say it again, the .280 is more then enough for North America without stepping into the 30 calibers. Also, super high vorticity rounds are another pet peeve with me; they burn up your barrel and are too fast to be effective. It's a good way to cripple an animal and end up losing it. And besides, they're over priced like your 7 Mag or anything in a .30 cal. A box of .280 on sale is $17 bucks and my .270 also...go figure. We can shoot all day without being hammered, which I'm sure you can't say that. But attempting to compare apples to apples using Remingtion's ballistic chart, both calibers using a 150 grain, nothing fancy, the 7 mag's velocity is 0.913% faster at 500 yards, Energy is 0.83% greater at 500 Yards and B.C. is the same at over twice the expense.



Please don't address any post to me again I enjoy this site too much.
 
LonePuma,
You might be on the wrong website. This is after all long range hunting.

As far as caliber for the OP, either one will do.
 
Warning! This thread is more than 14 years ago old.
It's likely that no further discussion is required, in which case we recommend starting a new thread. If however you feel your response is required you can still do so.
Top