7SAUM or 7 Sherman?

Winkfish

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 27, 2016
Messages
268
Location
Wisconsin
I am stuck in analysis paralysis and looking for you all to help straighten me out.

I have a Bighorn TL-3 short action, and a 1:8" twist #3 barrel blank that is 29", or 28" finished length. I am willing to cut this down as far as 20".

The goal is to be magazine fed, shoot 175 class bullets and have 2,200 fps and 1,500ft-lb to at least 500 yards. Both of these cartariges can achieve this in a 24" tube. If I go off load data at 24", I can reach that threshold at 525ish yards for the SAUM and roughly 700 yards with the Sherman. I have H-4350, and Retumbo on hand, and if reasonable I would start with Retumbo. H-1000 is starting to show up from time to time as well and that may be another powder option.

For the SAUM, it looks like it is easier to find someone who can chamber my barrel, the dies are a little cheaper, but getting brass appears to be impossible.

Sherman, most likely would need to do a reamer rental and find someone who will chamber it. Not having a ton of luck there, maybe you folks can point me to someone I can call to discuss the details. Dies are available as is the brass. It looks like there are some changes in flight to the sherman case that dies are in the process of being made however the reamers may not be out there yet for these updates? Do I go with the old case design or wait for the new ones?

I would like to get about 100 pieces of brass for either chambering and that should last a practical time in either instance.

This gun will be used as a hunting rig so barrel life is not very high on the list. Factory ammo is not a consideration either. If anyone has any recommendations either way please let me know.

Thank you,
 
I am stuck in analysis paralysis and looking for you all to help straighten me out.

I have a Bighorn TL-3 short action, and a 1:8" twist #3 barrel blank that is 29", or 28" finished length. I am willing to cut this down as far as 20".

The goal is to be magazine fed, shoot 175 class bullets and have 2,200 fps and 1,500ft-lb to at least 500 yards. Both of these cartariges can achieve this in a 24" tube. If I go off load data at 24", I can reach that threshold at 525ish yards for the SAUM and roughly 700 yards with the Sherman. I have H-4350, and Retumbo on hand, and if reasonable I would start with Retumbo. H-1000 is starting to show up from time to time as well and that may be another powder option.

For the SAUM, it looks like it is easier to find someone who can chamber my barrel, the dies are a little cheaper, but getting brass appears to be impossible.

Sherman, most likely would need to do a reamer rental and find someone who will chamber it. Not having a ton of luck there, maybe you folks can point me to someone I can call to discuss the details. Dies are available as is the brass. It looks like there are some changes in flight to the sherman case that dies are in the process of being made however the reamers may not be out there yet for these updates? Do I go with the old case design or wait for the new ones?

I would like to get about 100 pieces of brass for either chambering and that should last a practical time in either instance.

This gun will be used as a hunting rig so barrel life is not very high on the list. Factory ammo is not a consideration either. If anyone has any recommendations either way please let me know.

Thank you,
Have run a SAUM and although some components are tough to find right now, it is more common and easier to get things on a regular basis - has more data, and more etc... and more etc... and more etc....

The Sherman is Bad*ss and gives you more speed but if this is your only LR hunting/precision rifle, I would go with the SAUM. Why? Always a little hesitant when for all intensive purposes you can only get components from one spot. Added cost for reamers and other needs.

Either one for a hunting rig will be great. You have a short action, which will run but you might want to consider a a Med action length...use the other for something else. Recommend for the long run and the potential to run 180+ sized bullets that you do.
 
035ACFF7-2B42-495C-9BA5-DF69FBDDC8B7.jpeg
8730F11F-C2AD-415D-9DDF-5E71EF2FCC26.jpeg
219E368A-3ECB-4D8D-B453-CE8A5653D646.jpeg
 
I run a 7 sherman max on a long action. I have never had a problem getting brass over 400 peices now. I called Richard paid the rental. He shipped the reamer to my gunsmith no problems. I get 3189 fps 26" barrel with 151gr PVA Cayuga bullets. Starting to work with some 175s now.
Agree. He always has brass and reamers if you want the extra speed. Not knocking the max at all. It's awesome in it's on rights.
 
I am stuck in analysis paralysis and looking for you all to help straighten me out.

I have a Bighorn TL-3 short action, and a 1:8" twist #3 barrel blank that is 29", or 28" finished length. I am willing to cut this down as far as 20".

The goal is to be magazine fed, shoot 175 class bullets and have 2,200 fps and 1,500ft-lb to at least 500 yards. Both of these cartariges can achieve this in a 24" tube. If I go off load data at 24", I can reach that threshold at 525ish yards for the SAUM and roughly 700 yards with the Sherman. I have H-4350, and Retumbo on hand, and if reasonable I would start with Retumbo. H-1000 is starting to show up from time to time as well and that may be another powder option.

For the SAUM, it looks like it is easier to find someone who can chamber my barrel, the dies are a little cheaper, but getting brass appears to be impossible.

Sherman, most likely would need to do a reamer rental and find someone who will chamber it. Not having a ton of luck there, maybe you folks can point me to someone I can call to discuss the details. Dies are available as is the brass. It looks like there are some changes in flight to the sherman case that dies are in the process of being made however the reamers may not be out there yet for these updates? Do I go with the old case design or wait for the new ones?

I would like to get about 100 pieces of brass for either chambering and that should last a practical time in either instance.

This gun will be used as a hunting rig so barrel life is not very high on the list. Factory ammo is not a consideration either. If anyone has any recommendations either way please let me know.

Thank you,
The new /B chambers are the way to go and reamers, dies and brass are all in stock and should remain so. There are some top smiths who will have the reamers so you don't have to rent. Several smiths are listed on my website, But I would start with Axis Works in Tempe.
Call me anytime for info.
shermanwildcatcartridges.com
 
Top