Load test 3 what do you think? UPDATED

Discussion in 'Reloading' started by emn83, Dec 1, 2012.

  1. emn83

    emn83 Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    801
    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2012
    Finally got decent enough weather to go and do another load test. In my last test, I had 3 loads that stood out, at 45.0, 45.2 and 46.0 grains of Varget under my 155gn Berger hunting VLDs. For those 3, I had the following notes

    45.0: 0.46 MOA horizontal, no vertical
    45.2: 0.403MOA nice 3 shot cluster
    46.0: 0.452 MOA Nice 3 shot cluster (very slight ejector marking)


    Today when I went out, I had 2 purposes, 1 to sight in my new Vortex Viper PST, and, 2: to do some load testing on those 3 loads. on the first goal, I did OK, I think I have the 100 yard zero pretty well figured out. On the second, well, here's where I need some help.


    Conditions:
    Cloudy/misting rain
    Tempurature: 34 degrees
    Wind: no felt wind

    Here is my 100 yard target. Going from left to right are 45.0, 45.2 and 46.0 grains
    [​IMG]
    The 45.0 loads were a waste as far as testing, because I used the 2 sighters and 3 rounds to get on paper. The 2 hits just to the left of the dot are the last 2 shots at that charge weight.

    The 45.2gn shots formed a horizontal line 0.73 MOA long, about .5 MOA low

    the 46.0gn shots formed a 0.423 MOA group 1 MOA low.

    I adjusted my zero .75 MOA, splitting the difference between the 2.

    Here is my target at 200 yards:
    [​IMG]
    I used the bottom left corner of the square for point of aim.

    The 45.0 loads formed a group that was 1.45 MOA, with one shot landing off the papoer. the center of the group was 2.434 inches low

    the 45.2 loads formed a 0.36 moa (.75in) group. the center of the group was 1.9 inches below point of aim

    The 46.0 group had one called flier, making for a group of .88 MOA (2 of the rounds were touching). The center of the group was 2.4 inches below point of aim.


    Any thoughts? I'm really starting to think that 45.2gn is my load, but that flier on the 46.0 load has me questioning thatt.
     
    Last edited: Dec 1, 2012
  2. Bob L.

    Bob L. Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    182
    Joined:
    Jun 11, 2010
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    I would re shoot the 2nd and 3rd group again, can you shoot those at 300yards?
     

  3. emn83

    emn83 Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    801
    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2012
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    That's what I was thinking too. I can shoot 300 at my range. it goes to 450, I've been stepping it back incrementally as my confidence goes up. after this last outing, I'm starting to feel pretty good. The rifle has been doing awesome. Think my next test will take her out to 300 and see what happens. have to wait for good weather again. My car doesn't make it all the range, so it's walk in, walk out, and walking to place targets, bad weather is no fun
     
  4. Dr. Vette

    Dr. Vette Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    2,033
    Joined:
    Dec 30, 2009
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    I'd reshoot, and throw in a 45.6 group. I suspect you'll see that the trend continues and 46.0 is the smallest.

    I assume (?) you tried over 46?
    46.3 might be interesting and I suspect you'll see it widen up a bit.
     
  5. emn83

    emn83 Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    801
    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2012
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    I have gotten ejector marks intermittently at 46.0, which is why I kept that as my top load weight.


    I just loaded 5 more of the 45.2 and 46.0. When I shot before, I did shoot a 45.5, and it grouped quite a bit bigger than the 45.2 and 46.0...I may load up a few at other weights just to see though...tomorrow is supposed to be nicer weather, so I may try some 45.6 and maybe a 46.3, just to re-check at those weights. Going to try at 300 yards if i go out tomorrow
     
  6. SBruce

    SBruce Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    1,786
    Joined:
    Oct 31, 2009
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    I am with Dr. Vette,

    Might just pay to try 45.6 again, one more time just to confirm if nothing else. I'd try it along with 45.2 and 46 under ideal wind conditions at 200 or 300 yds.

    Good Luck and let us know.
     
  7. royinidaho

    royinidaho Writers Guild

    Messages:
    8,853
    Joined:
    Jan 20, 2004
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    I think you are to a point where 3 shot groups aren't enough to make a quality decision.

    I'd suggest going a bit over 46 grains but if you are at maximum you are at maximum. The reason for the suggestion is that I have found when the group is horizontal as with the 45.2 - 100 yd group then symmetrical as the 46 - 100 yard group, the next step up may well shot a vertical tread. Showing the load the rifle likes as the 46 grain load.

    The 200 yard targets show a bit of a shift in the formation of the 45.2 grain load from horizontal to vertical. A lot of things could cause that.

    The 200 yd 46 grain load shows better potential than the 45.2 grain load. Why the flier? Who knows?:)

    I'd consider loading 5 each of the 45.2 and 46 grain loads and shoot them round robin being calm cool and collected the whole time.:) Then make the decision.

    In reality you can't go too far wrong for hunting purposes with either one.

    Don't shoot too much. A callus on the trigger finger causes fliers.:D
     
  8. emn83

    emn83 Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    801
    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2012
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    Last night I loaded up five each of the 45.2 and the 46.0, it's supposed to be decent weather today, mid 30s, but maybe cloudy. If I get a chance, I'll test tohose 2 loads again, and hopefully be done for the winter with testing.

    any thoughts on range for the test. the 200 yards seemed to be a good distance, but I can push it out further
     
  9. Dr. Vette

    Dr. Vette Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    2,033
    Joined:
    Dec 30, 2009
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    200 yards is fine, but I'd still try a load in between those two. Why? Because you're looking for a pattern. What you'd really like to see is a transition from 45.2 to 46.0 going through 45.6.

    As noted above, do them in round robin, even if you stick with your 2 loads. 5 min between shots, allowing the barrel to cool between each.

    Let us know what you get.
     
  10. emn83

    emn83 Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    801
    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2012
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    I did a round robin before, with 6 loads, I didn't have 45.6, but I did have 45.5, and it was quite a bit larger of a group, that's why i was sticking with these two loads, they had produced the best results.
     
  11. Dr. Vette

    Dr. Vette Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    2,033
    Joined:
    Dec 30, 2009
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    Noted.

    Ideally I think it'd be nice to see this as your load progresses:

    [​IMG]
     
  12. emn83

    emn83 Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    801
    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2012
    Re: Load test 3 what do you think?

    UPDATE. with some frustration at myself. So, I took the rifle out today, had 20 rounds, 10 each at 45.2, and 46.0.

    Conditions:
    Temp:34 degrees
    Humidity: 96%
    Sky cover: cloudy/foggy
    Wind: from 3 0'clock at about 7mph ( a guess, didn't feel the wind when placing the target, but it was definitely there when I retrieved the 300 yard target)

    Distance: 200 and 300 yards.

    On both targets, the left is 45.2gr, and the right is 46.0gr

    Here's my 200 yard target:
    [​IMG]
    This was mostly on me, I wasn't waiting that much between shots (Dr. Vette, I got an update on your post between shooting 200 and 300 yards) There are 2 called fliers, one on each target, because, well, I was an idiot and shot the wrong target once with each load....hooray for being anxious to shoot and making stupid mistakes!

    For judging drop, I used an estimate MV of 2850, and dialed up 3.8 MOA from my 100 yard zero...seems pretty close

    anyway, at 300, there were more definite results:
    [​IMG]

    The 45.2 has 4 shots I can see, not actually sure where the 5th shot is :rolleyes: annoyed at that one. POA was the bottom right corner of the square.

    the 46.0 target has a nice horizontal string, except that one shot that his higher up, when these two old timers came in and slammed the door on the range right as I was squeezing the trigger. POA was the bottom left corner of the square. I definitely need more practice judging and adjusting for wind
     
  13. emn83

    emn83 Well-Known Member

    Messages:
    801
    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2012
    Okay. not sure if this is helpful, but I took a pic of all the targets I have from yesterday and today.

    The order in the pic goes, from top to bottom

    100 yards
    200 yards
    200 yards
    300 yards

    as always, the target on the left is 45.2 grains, and the target on the right is 46.0 grains

    [​IMG]
     
  14. royinidaho

    royinidaho Writers Guild

    Messages:
    8,853
    Joined:
    Jan 20, 2004
    Suggestions, as there seems to be a reoccurring something going on:

    1: start today taking 20mg Celexa for 21 days and shoot again. (Works for me :D)

    2: If you know of a good shooter, most probably will be your wife, let them give it a go. Don't let any stone unturned. :)

    R U chronoing each shot. Maybe something like neck tension is raising it's ugly head. . .

    Just thinkin':rolleyes: Which is a bad thing for me.:D