Crispin Goodall,
I am sorry if I offended you with my post, I reread it and find nothing offensive at all from what I stated.
I answered the question with all the possible problems that I could think of from the information give at the time.
If the rifle was shooting 1/3 moa why would there be 3/4" taken off the barrel when obviously taking off just a few thousandths to clean up the crown would have done the job.
ANSWER
Because the end of the muzzle was pitted which was posted after my original response was it not.
It is also very easy to over lap a bore to make it loose in spots. I have no experience with PGW and was not stating that they ruined this barrel, only that this could be another explination for why the consistancy of this barrel went south.
The comment about "there is no reason to screw it up like this" was directed toward the unlikelyhood that recrowning would destroy the barrels accuracy potential if done with the right tools, not that PGW is not capable of performing this job as I know they are.
Now that you have hammered me and questioned my intentions and motivations on this board please allow me to respond.
I do not solicit on this board in any way unless asked for information directly by a poster or asked what a proceedure costs to do.
I am a gunsmith and I respond on this board as such. Not selling my goods but offering my experience to those that ask a question that I feel I can be of some help with.
The problem with the web is you can read into my posts whatever meaning you want to depending on your state of mind.
I assure you that I was not directing flames toward PGWs and would not do that toward any other poster on this board unless defending my postion. Even then I will give my opinion and give one that is based on factual experience just as you would do.
Obviously you did not read my response very well either as I stated the following:
"Basically, you want to keep the same pressure and velocity but you may have to find a new sweet spot for your load length by shortening your barrel by 3/4" seems to have effected the harmonics of your barrel.
IT MAY SUPRISE YOU HOW YOUR RIFLE WILL SHOOT WITH SHORTER LENGTHS."
There is more before the quote in my original post which you obviously missed, I said the same **** thing as you.
Then after that, I said:
"If this does not work I would be a little concerned about the lapping of the bore."
A problem was presented and with the information offered in the original post, I give my primary opinion of what would solve the problem, tayloring the load to the new barrel length, same as your suggestion.
If that did not work then there would have obviously been more wrong with the rifle.
Your right, I did not know alot of the information about the problem before I responded but I answered honestly about what could be causing the problem from a mechanical stand point and I stand by those comments, they all could cause a rifle to perform this way.
I never did attack PGW, I never was building myself up at all, just answering the question as to what may be the problem, pure and simple.
Appearantly we both look at our work in the same manor, let the rifle and handguns do the talking. I am just answering questions which I though was the point to this board.
If I am new to the board and you feel I am stepping on your toes, I apologize but I enjoy talking with everyone on here and will continue.
From the thanks I get from many of the posters i respond to I see no reason to stop helping answer questions that are answered.
If I was blowing my own horn, would i not be starting the posts to draw attention to me? I only respond to asked questions as a whole.
Your interpritaion of my posts is your problem, not mine.
Again, you know as little about me as I do you, but you make just as many assumptions as you claim I do. If you truely knew me you would truely feel foolish for your comments toward me and toward my responses to all the posts on this board.
You may know Len very well, I do not know him at all, but I have been around long enough to know that if I was offending the owner of LRH, I would have heard about it by now and asked to stop what I was doing.
I am not looking for work, do you know what kind of head ache it would be to do work for a Canadian being a US gunsmith. I hve no reason to do this, I have no reason to drum up business this way.
I enjoy taking guns, I enjoy long range shooting and I am more then willing to share any experience I have with anyone who asks, FREE OF CHARGE!! As will you I believe.
If I offended you for some reason I am also sorry because I have never intended to do that.
I would like you to point out my history of flaming other smiths please. Show me the posts and I will admit that I did it because I do not do this.
Again, I was given certain information and asked a question on what could possibly be causing this. I gave a solid response which you refer to as, what was that, oh yes, "thinly veiled answers".
Whatever you think fella.
I hope someday you can get used to someone else answering questions along with you, the more the marrier in my book, to bad you feel I am stepping on your toes and offending every other smith on the planet at the same time.
Kirby Allen(50)