Non-expanding bullet performance
Robbor,
It has been my experience that if it doesn't expand at all the animal is still just as dead and just as quick but with little to no blood trail recovery in some types of country can be difficult at best.
Shawn,
One comment in your post surprised me - that if a bullet doesn't expand at all the animal is still just as dead and "just as quick". Below is a post I made in a thread on another forum discussing bullet failures and the pros and cons of using tougher or more fragile bullets. I don't hunt big game with non-expanding bullets, but I've had two first-hand experiences where expanding bullets didn't expand. The animals were both double-lunged and they both lived for a long time compared to typical results from an expanding bullet. Following is my post describing these two incidents. I'd be interested in hearing your's or any others experiences on the lethality of non expanding bullets on big game with non-brain or non-central nervous system hits.
"Even the Nosler Ballistic Tips will, on occasion, fail to expand. My first experience was a Dall sheep ram in about 1999 in the Alaska range. I was shooting 150 gr BTs from a 280 Improved at a chronographed muzzle velocity of 2975 fps. I shot the ram from 13 yards, a broadside shot to the center of the ribs. The ram snapped his head up, turned 180 degrees and looked across the river bottom at some sheep on the other side of the valley. I was trying to figure out how I could have missed at 13 yds. After 15-20 seconds I saw a tiny red spot appear on the white hair of the rib cage, which confirmed the bullet hit right where I intended. I waited another minute while the ram stood there, and then I stood up from just 13 yards away. He didn't know where I was until I stood, and at that motion the ram jumped and then trotted down the hillside, slowing down and coming to a stop about 80 yards away. He stood there for several more minutes and then lay down. I kept thinking the animal had to die any second, so rather than shoot again and damage any more meat or the cape, I watched and waited. Again, I figured the ram was good as dead. After about 5 minutes the ram laid his head down and appeared very tired. After about 20 minutes had elapsed from the time I shot the ram, and he was STILL alive, I approached the ram. His his head was bobbing some and his breathing was somewhat labored. The ram was sickly, but as I got up to within about 15 feet, I was surprised when he jumped to his feet and took off. His gate was unbalanced and I quickly fired a second bullet from a rear quartering position into the boiler room. The second bullet opened and flattened the ram like a pile driver. Upon skinning the animal, I found a 1/4" entrance hole and 1/4" exit hole from my first shot. So say what you want. Even the lighter jacketed, unbonded Nosler Ballistic Tips will sometimes fail to open up.
About 5 years ago I observed another failure of a Nosler Ballistic tip - this time on a smallish black bear. My hunting partner shot the bear broadside through the ribs with a 338 Winchester Magnum from about 230 yards, with a 200 grain Nosler Ballistic Tip. We could tell the bear was hit, and we were both surprised when the bear spun around and continued to run for some distance across the mountain side, since the shot was taken from a solid rest. We had to shoot the bear on the move a couple more times to stop him before he reached the alders and brush. While skinning out the bear, we were able to identify the location of the first shot, by the small through & through hole through the ribcage, and knowing the position of the bear on the other shots. If that first bullet had expanded, the bear would have gone down in short order.
Although most sheep, black bear, and blacktail deer sized game I have shot with Nosler BTs have gone down instantly or very shortly after impact, I offer these two instances where for whatever reason, the BTs didn't expand and kill the animals quickly or effectively, even though both animals were double-lunged with broadside hits.
I now use Nosler Accubonds more often than BTs. The Accubonds shoot just as well for me, and basically to the same point of impact as the BTs. And the ABs spread less lead into the meat surrounding the bullet path. Plus - I bump into an unintended brown bear every now and then and I like the idea of having the ABs in the chamber compared to a BT, just in case the bear comes at me rather than heading the other way."