close
Long Range Hunting Online Magazine


Go Back   Long Range Hunting Online Magazine > Hunting > Elk Hunting

Elk Hunting Techniques For Elk Hunting

Reply

Adequate Cartridge for Elk???

LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #22  
Unread 04-22-2014, 08:33 AM
Bronze Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2014
Posts: 56
Re: Adequate Cartridge for Elk???

Because an Elk will retreat on a threat, while a lion might decide to grab your throat, like he does to everything he eats, or decides to kill. And lions even kill little cub lions because he didn't sire them.
Reply With Quote
  •   #23  
    Unread 04-22-2014, 08:40 AM
    Platinum Member
     
    Join Date: Nov 2008
    Location: SW Montana
    Posts: 5,514
    Re: Adequate Cartridge for Elk???

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by MMERSS View Post
    A male lion weighs about half as much as an elk. If shot placement is so critical shouldn’t a lion hunter be capable of harvesting their animal with say a 243? A lion, rino or hippo hunter shouldn’t need those bigger cartridges with good shot placement because it’s been said many many times here, shot placement is critical…So the lion hunter doesn’t need those large cartridges when practically any reasonable cartridge and bullet with proper shot placement will work, do they? Should the mentality of harvesting an elk be that much different than harvesting a lion or other game.


    There is adequate, there is better, there is much better, and there is just plain the not so smart choice.
    Comparing the killing of a cat species with low velocity non expanding bullets to shooting a hooved animal with high velocity expanding round is a little over the top don't you think!
    __________________
    "Pain is weakness leaving your body"
    Reply With Quote

      #24  
    Unread 04-22-2014, 10:34 AM
    RHC RHC is offline
    Silver Member
     
    Join Date: Apr 2014
    Location: Helena, MT
    Posts: 137
    Re: Adequate Cartridge for Elk???

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by MMERSS View Post
    A male lion weighs about half as much as an elk. If shot placement is so critical shouldn’t a lion hunter be capable of harvesting their animal with say a 243? A lion, rino or hippo hunter shouldn’t need those bigger cartridges with good shot placement because it’s been said many many times here, shot placement is critical…So the lion hunter doesn’t need those large cartridges when practically any reasonable cartridge and bullet with proper shot placement will work, do they? Should the mentality of harvesting an elk be that much different than harvesting a lion or other game.


    There is adequate, there is better, there is much better, and there is just plain the not so smart choice.
    We're talking about a elk, not something that wants to turn you into a snack.
    __________________
    Opportunity follows the beep...
    Reply With Quote
      #25  
    Unread 04-22-2014, 03:57 PM
    Gold Member
     
    Join Date: Oct 2012
    Location: Colorado
    Posts: 816
    Re: Adequate Cartridge for Elk???

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by MMERSS View Post
    A male lion weighs about half as much as an elk. If shot placement is so critical shouldn’t a lion hunter be capable of harvesting their animal with say a 243? A lion, rino or hippo hunter shouldn’t need those bigger cartridges with good shot placement because it’s been said many many times here, shot placement is critical…So the lion hunter doesn’t need those large cartridges when practically any reasonable cartridge and bullet with proper shot placement will work, do they? Should the mentality of harvesting an elk be that much different than harvesting a lion or other game.


    There is adequate, there is better, there is much better, and there is just plain the not so smart choice.
    I completely get what you are saying MMERSS...makes you think twice about those energy numbers. Bottom line for me, if I were looking to buy a rifle for elk hunting, I would be buying the largest caliber rifle that I can shoot accurately. And that is for a similar reason to that of a person hunting a lion...you want the quickest kill possible. I know an elk won't kill me, but chasing a blood trail for miles on end might
    Reply With Quote
      #26  
    Unread 04-22-2014, 06:02 PM
    Gold Member
     
    Join Date: Feb 2013
    Posts: 912
    Re: Adequate Cartridge for Elk???

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by bigngreen View Post
    Comparing the killing of a cat species with low velocity non expanding bullets to shooting a hooved animal with high velocity expanding round is a little over the top don't you think!
    ^^^ Is this what you think? If so why is it over the top? Sometimes with decisions it's not as much about "what" is chosen but rather "why" it's choosen.

    I could justify why the quote is not over the top but that's not necessary.
    __________________
    Shoot CONFIDENT, Shoot SMART, Shoot STRAIGHT

    Last edited by MMERSS; 04-22-2014 at 07:00 PM.
    Reply With Quote
      #27  
    Unread 04-22-2014, 06:08 PM
    Gold Member
     
    Join Date: Feb 2013
    Posts: 912
    Re: Adequate Cartridge for Elk???

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by RHC View Post
    We're talking about a elk, not something that wants to turn you into a snack.

    I don't recall mentioning anything about a game animal wanting to turn something into a snack. Should that make any difference on selection of a cartridge?
    __________________
    Shoot CONFIDENT, Shoot SMART, Shoot STRAIGHT
    Reply With Quote
      #28  
    Unread 04-22-2014, 07:05 PM
    Gold Member
     
    Join Date: Feb 2013
    Posts: 912
    Re: Adequate Cartridge for Elk???

    Quote:
    Originally Posted by cohunter14 View Post
    I know an elk won't kill me, but chasing a blood trail for miles on end might
    Let's not find out please!!!!
    __________________
    Shoot CONFIDENT, Shoot SMART, Shoot STRAIGHT
    Reply With Quote
    Reply

    Bookmarks

    Thread Tools
    Display Modes



    All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:21 PM.


    Powered by vBulletin ©2000 - 2016, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
    Content Management Powered by vBadvanced CMPS
    All content ©2010-2015 Long Range Hunting, LLC