my daughter wants a mule deer gun for our 1st muledeer hunt together was thinking of 280rem. what do we need
1 doner action (probably savage or stevens)
2 new barrel
3 recoil lug
5 scope &mounts
is there anything else we might need ,she allready shoots a 7/08 out to 350-400yards pretty good but wants a BIGGER GUN. she also wants to be involved in mechanics of build (reason for savage) so it is HER rifle. she is only 5.1" so i think 7mag is out.any suggestions would be welcomed this hunt is what she wants for graduation from collage with honors in enginering so dad is proud and happy to take her hunting
Well is she wants a 7mm what about a muzzle break. It will feel like a 243. win. if not i know its not bigger but what about something like a 6.5 creedmoore, or 260 remington, 270. wsm or something. Good, fast, flat, accurate, hard hitting, little recoil.
All these are good rounds, heck even the 243. win would put a mule deer on its ass out too 400 yards. My neighbor drilled a 322 LBS, 170" mule deer at 387 yards and dropped him in his tracks.
Congratulations on raising a female engineer. My youngest daughter is a Civil engineer out of Cal Poly Pomona (PE in PA, NY, ME) with a Masters from ND.
Your daughter shoots a 7mm-08 with no trouble, she could easily step up to a .30-06 or .308. Either would work and they are both really good North American big game cartridges.
While 7mm bullets have a lot to recommend them in a .284 Winchester, .280 Remington, or one of the 7mm magnums, if one is going to go to the trouble to upgrade from a 7mm-08, and still shoot a reasonable weight carry around rifle with out ear plugs (i.e. no muzzle break), the .30-06 and .308 have a lot to recommend them. They are about equivelant for bullets of 180g and lighter. Both shoot a 150g bullet at 3,000 fps or more. They aren't sexey, trendy, or flashy, but they get the job done with monotonous regularity on what ever you point them at.
The next step up is a .300 WSM or .300 Win MAG, either of which requires a 10 lb or heavier rifle for comfortable shooting with out a brake, and frankly they don't have an advantage commensurate with the added grief for hunting mule deer.
In any case, shooting beyond 500 yards, be prepared to spend more on the scope than the rifle.
With a little bit of help it's possible to build a 1/2 - 3/4 MOA Savage with a Factory model 12 action, pre-chambered barrel from Shilin or equivelant, a good stock, and some time doing a good bedding job. The work can be done on a garage work bench with a few tools.
The rifle will deserve a good scope - probably costing more than the rifle. Done right, with just a bit of routine maintainance, that rifle will last for a life time of hunting.
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for nature cannot be fooled." R. Feynman. (Last sentence of the Feynman appendix to the Space Shuttle Challenger Report.)
geargrinder her disciple is mech.
geargrinder & olveralan why 284win over 280rem
matt muzzel break is not out of my thoughts but i just dont know much about 7wsm
guys i think she just wants a semicustom gun of her own
last nite found a 270 savage at pawnshop for right price so we have action
btw she wants to build it on her own with some help from me so i think thats where were we are at JWW
Is she willing to wear hearing protection while hunting?
Do you expect relatively quick shooting while hunting?
If she doesn't want to wear hearing protection, and if shots may be quick enough that she doesn't have time to put them on/in, then I'd suggest no muzzle break.
Do you or her reload? If not, 280 or 30-06 is hard to beat. Overall, easy to get ammo and not enough recoil that a break is needed. If you are into reloading, then 284 Win, 7mm WSM, 280 AI, the list goes on.
Don't forget a Pachmayer Decelerator or Limbsaver recoil pad, how about the accutrigger...?? The bigger the performance, the more the recoil, especially in a 9 lb with scope (or less) rifle. Most women I've seen like a rifle that's not very heavy to carry.