Long Range Hunting Online Magazine


Go Back   Long Range Hunting Online Magazine > Rifles, Reloading, Optics, Equipment > Reloading

Reloading Techniques For Reloading


Reply

Do I need to neck turn?

 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
  #15  
Old 06-17-2013, 04:54 AM
Platinum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Tucson Az
Posts: 1,232
Re: Do I need to neck turn?

I have a 30 BR that is using .0105" neck wall thickness with .001" release per side.

I would say you could go even thinner but if you use a repeater recoil might move the bullet too easily as the thinner walls don't offer much neck tension.


Getting back to neck turning. I bumped into a great article on accurateshooter.com
where they discuss no turn vs turned necks. This is a BR site and naturally the article below is discussing BR equipment. So take it as it was intended. LR hunting certainly has different considerations such as having to work with more neck tension as most of us use repeaters:



Tunnel Tests Show Superiority of Turned Necks

Turning necks is widely, if not universally, done by short-range benchresters shooting 6 PPC and 22 PPC cartridges. On the other hand, many long-range shooters, using bigger cases with longer bullets, have had great success with sorted, but non-neck-turned Lapua brass. For example, Richard Schatz has set multiple world records, and won many major matches shooting his no-turn Dashers.

Turned necks still completely dominate the short-range benchrest game. But, do we have any hard evidence of how much of an advantage turned necks offer? And, is it fair to say that turning necks is less advantageous with longer, heavier bullets typically used for 600- and 1000-yard benchrest?

Lou Murdica is a very skilled benchrest shooter in California. This editor has personally seen Lou finish first in a short-range BR match competing against some of the best shooters on the West Coast. Lou does a lot of serious comparison testing of components, and he has access to an indoor tunnel. The tunnel allows Lou to eliminate (or at least minimize) wind effects when testing ammo. Over the past few months Lou has been testing turned vs. unturned necks, and he recently posted some interesting conclusions.



Lou writes: “I don’t want to say that what some people have done is wrong for them, but I have been testing for nine months, shooting three to four times a week. I have found that there IS a difference between turned brass and unturned brass. Turned brass has shot better every single time in my tests. However, I have also come to the conclusion that if you shoot with very, very light neck tension it is hard to tell the difference between turned brass or unturned brass. If you shoot with any neck tension, though, turning does make a difference and you can get flyers with unturned brass.

The benefits of neck-turning showed up more in the 22 calibers than the 6mm. Moreover, I shot thick necks in the 6mm better than the 22. I found that the 22 wanted more release that the 6mm. I could get the 6mm to shoot tight necks easier than the 22.

For what it’s worth, I think that everyone should at least clean up their brass with a turner. All these years people have tried to find short cuts in shooting benchrest and every time we always come back to the same steps and care in making brass as before. I think it’s a given that if you want to compete at the top you cannot take short cuts. You may get by once or twice, but in the long run it will hurt you.

Since 1991 when I was on the winning team at the 1st World Shoot in France, I started to experiment and shoot every weird thing I could find or build. I tried more crap, bought and built more guns and while doing this I tried to shoot every shoot I could across the country. I took Tony Boyer’s class three years back, and the first thing he told me was pick a couple of guns out of all of them and shoot 6 PPC and nothing else for the next couple years. He told me to spend my money on barrels for those guns. Well, I did as he suggested and boy, it made a difference in my shooting.

What I’m trying to say to all the guys that have been shooting benchrest for a while and are starting to travel to the bigger matches is, stick with proven goods that have dominated for years, like the 6 PPC, with turned necks. You can try the weird stuff in practice.”

Neck-Turning, Neck Tension, and Longer Bullets
–Does a Different Rule Apply?
Keep in mind that Lou is primarily talking about short-range PPC loads with short, flat-base bullets. Those who are shooting beyond 400 yards typically use longer boat-tail, high-BC bullets. These have a smaller, less pronounced pressure ring, a much longer bearing surface, and weigh two to three times as much as a 6mm PPC match bullet. The longer bullets are also propelled by slower powders, operating in a somewhat lower pressure range than is common for a competitive 6 PPC load. Notably, top 600-yard shooters like Terry Brady and Richard Schatz have found that these long bullets prefer relatively light neck tension, meaning the neck is sized to just .001-.002 under a loaded round.

This takes us back to one of Lou Murdica’s observations. Lou said: “I have also come to the conclusion that if you shoot with very, very light neck tension it is hard to tell the difference between turned brass or unturned brass.” Though Lou was mostly working with the lighter bullets, perhaps his observations explain why unturned brass has worked surprisingly well with the heavier bullets with long bearing surfaces. Since those long bullets typically work best with relatively light tension, maybe the benefits of turning necks are not so great, and that’s why someone like Richard Schatz can win with no-turn Dasher brass. Richard was the 2007 IBS 600-yard Shooter of the Year.

This is not to say that turned necks can’t benefit the 600-yard shooter. Murdica also shoots 600 yards, and he believes neck-turning helps long-range accuracy. Don Nielson absolutely dominated the NBRSA 600-yard Nationals using brass that was carefully neck-turned with his Pumpkin neck turning tool. Don strongly believes that his turned necks helped with accuracy and shot-to-shot consistency. So the jury is still out on the merits of neck-turning with longer bullets in bigger cases, but we applaud Lou Murdica for doing some serious research and putting in the “tunnel time” to confirm the benefits of turned necks for the short-range PPC shooters.
Reply With Quote
  #16  
Old 06-18-2013, 06:53 PM
Platinum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Posts: 2,114
Re: Do I need to neck turn?

Many folks get 1/4 MOA accuracy at 100 yards, 1/3 at 300, 1/2 at 600 and 3/4 MOA at 1000 yards with unturned necks. As long as the neck wall thickness has less than a .001" spread, they're good to go.

Turning necks to a uniform thickness takes a 1/4 MOA (or better) at worst rifle and ammo to see the difference; plus someone who can consistantly shoot that stuff that well. Benchresters may well see a 1/16 to 1/8 MOA improvement shooting their super accurate rifles in free recoil. Folks shooting anything off their shoulder holding them with their hands as they rest atop something on a bench are hard pressed to see that much difference.

Neck walls can be 1/25th caliber (bore diameter) thick at a minimum. 30 caliber cases would then have a minimum neck wall thickness of .012". Some folks go thinner, but that may cause sizing problems with most dies unless you use one with bushings of the right size.

All in my opinion, naturally.

Fact: turning bottleneck case necks (on cases headspacing on their shoulder) to uniform diameters does not help center them in the chamber neck when they're fired. They float clear of the chamber neck wall by 1 up to a few thousandths. Those cases are centered in the chamber shoulder by their own shoulder. If the case neck's .001" off center on the case shoulder, it'll be off center in the chamber neck by the same amount.
Reply With Quote
  #17  
Old 06-19-2013, 05:35 AM
Platinum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Tucson Az
Posts: 1,232
Re: Do I need to neck turn?

IMO and the author in article above, is that turning the necks was all about consistency. When the neck wall thicknesses are all the same the result is similar neck tension and bullet release which aides in accuracy.
Reply With Quote
  #18  
Old 06-19-2013, 06:23 AM
Platinum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Posts: 2,114
Re: Do I need to neck turn?

Quote:
Originally Posted by AZShooter View Post
IMO and the author in article above, is that turning the necks was all about consistency. When the neck wall thicknesses are all the same the result is similar neck tension and bullet release which aides in accuracy.
In the ammo industry, bullet release force is the term used to express how easy or hard it is to get the bullet out of the case. They use tools to measure how many pounds of force it takes to pull the bullet out. How tight the case neck grips the bullet as well as the friction between bullet and case determines the force needed to do so.

With a collet type bullet puller gripping the bullet and weight added to a bucket attached to a shell holder with the round in it, the amount of weight needed to pull the bullet out could be easily and very accurately measured. In my tests of turning necks from exact thickness all the way around to just enough to remove brass 1/2 to 3/4 the way around the neck and having no more than .001" spread in wall thickness, the release force average and spread did not significantly change. Nor was there any accuracy difference through 1000 yards

7.62 NATO match ammo has a release force spec of at least 40 pounds. My measurements of both M118 and M852 ammo showed an average force of around 50 pounds with a 20% spread. Yet that ammo would shoot under 1 MOA at 600 yards, under 1/3 MOA at 100 yards. Good commercial .308 Win. match ammo I've measured has release forces around 20 to 25 pounds with the same spread; it's shot 1/4 MOA at 100 and 2/3 MOA at 600 yards.

Sierra Bullets does no prep on cases used to test their bullets for accuracy. Nor do they work up loads for a new barrel or new lots of bullets, primers, cases and powder. Their best match bullets go into 1/4 MOA at 200 yards from such cases using these procedures.

All of which to me means, unless you can shoot your stuff into no more than 1/4 MOA at 100 yards, turning case necks to exact, or nearly so, thickness is a waste of time. There's other things that'll improve your ammo's accuracy that's a lot easier to do.
Reply With Quote
  #19  
Old 06-19-2013, 06:49 AM
Platinum Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: Tucson Az
Posts: 1,232
Re: Do I need to neck turn?

Thanks for those details Bart B.

I will continue to use no turn neck reamers for most of my barrels. I will still turn down my 30 BR's neck to fit that tight chamber or any brass that ends up more than .015" after necking down.
Reply With Quote
  #20  
Old 06-19-2013, 04:05 PM
Platinum Member
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: NC, oceanfront
Posts: 3,226
Re: Do I need to neck turn?

Bart, the problem with a 'bullet release force' measurement is that it does not actually represent 'bullet grip' , or tension. In fact, if not controlled, it might mean nothing at all.

I compare seating forces with an electronic loadcell, as I've yet to design/built an actual tool for grip force measure. I do so knowing that this is relative and a not real internal ballistic factor.
But since I control every aspect of it so well, it does work to meet it's intent for me.
That is, I can actually see a measure implying tighter gripping force on both my meter and chrono.

There are two valid neck tension paths related:
1. Lighter tension = lower tension variance = lower ES and better tune(with load A)
2. Heavier tension = consistent pressure peak = lower ES and better tune(with load B)
They conflict, and there are of course gains AND prices to pay elsewhere, with each(and everything).

Often PB BR shooters need both, so they turn necks thinner and jam seat to effectively accomplish both. This is purely part of reaching tune at competitive load levels, and in capacities way smaller than hunting capacity cartridges. A disadvantage is in loosing seating adjustment off the lands.
Reloaders for distant shooting are challenged with more abstracts, and there are no trends that hold in neck thickness. But, with this there are fewer constraints(it's wide open).

A big ole Weatherby shooter might get his system shooting pretty good for a big ole Weatherby, 1/8" off the lands and with necks 15thou thick, while breaking every rule in point blank BR.
That's fine, it's not a tiny little BR toy.
Reply With Quote
  #21  
Old 06-19-2013, 06:47 PM
Gold Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Wolfesville, MD
Posts: 805
Re: Do I need to neck turn?

Quote:
Originally Posted by ZSteinle View Post
7mmSAUM, shooting necked down norma 300 SAUM brass
Reamer neck diameter 0.321
Loaded case neck diameter 0.316
Full lenght sized unloaded case 0.314
Fired case diameter 0.319
redding standard fell length sizer was the die I used

Reason I ask is I loaded up some ammo off of Berger reloading manual. used their 168 VLD to start with but was shooting 162 hornday match bullets so I figured it would be fine but was showing some pretty good amounts of pressure. fired 2 rounds and stopped there.

Load was 56 gr. of 4831sc at 3.060" OAL

My standard load w/ a 180 Berger is 58 gr of H-4831 59 starts to show some ejector marks. Two grains more for the 168 Berger loaded at 2.9" OAL right at the lands
Your OAL would be an extremely hard Jam in my rifle and would spike pressures with a lot less powder.
As far as turning necks, unless your reamer is a tight neck don't do it. You will work your brass too much and need annealing or will split. Since you are using Norma brass the neck consistancy is better than most others.
When accuracy is measured in .001" or less, everything you can do to make your rifle more accurate is worth it, but in hunting will 1/3" MOA make a difference? Maybe over 1500 yds. I shot the 6 Dasher in comp and that rifle w/ turned necks have shot numerous groups measuring under 2.2" with an agg of 2.82"
In short range I lost a match at the Super Shoot some yrs ago at 200 yds by .0001" yes 1/10,000" and the total for the day was .2482" agg, Damn Jack Sutton of Hart Barrels
Reply With Quote
Reply

Bookmarks

Thread Tools
Display Modes


Current Poll
Do you watch outdoor shows live or by recording them?
Always recorded - 13.10%
112 Votes
Mostly recorded - 24.21%
207 Votes
Sometimes recorded - 15.09%
129 Votes
Rarely or never recorded - 47.60%
407 Votes
Total Votes: 855
You may not vote on this poll.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:14 AM.


Powered by vBulletin ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Content Management Powered by vBadvanced CMPS
All content ©2010-2014 Long Range Hunting, LLC