A velocity measurement would be beneficial, the mid sixties in weight sounds a pretty HOT.

IIRC one of the most widely used loads for the 300 WSM & RL-17 is 68.0grns... with a bullet in the
168-180 range (can't remember which)I am shooting a Lazzeroni Patriot, which is nearly identical in capacity, i'm running 67.0 grns with a 168TTSX. It is as hot as I intend to go, with noticably sticky bolt above 67.5grns. I'd say you have to be reaching your pressure ceiling, but that is long on speculation & short on fact
Flattening primers is a good reasonable identifier of pressure... but not always. What about bolt stick? Case Measurements? Primer pocket life? Any ejector marks? Etc...
Access to a chrony would be helpful....
Edit: Looking again, you stated cratering... are you seeing that too? Or just the flattening?