It's just me being a pain, again.
I just read thru the entire 10 page post on the Tommy. A bunch of good stuff, BUT......
Based on your (and your friends) experience, could you give a quick rundown on what you feel is the approximate correct barrel lengths for a couple of different .30 cal. cases?
Specifically, I was wondering about a standard 300 RUM, a standard 300 Win mag, and a 30-338 Win mag.
I think it's time for me to step up to a new barrel, and I don't know which way I'm going yet. Your answer MAY make a difference.
I like longer barrels and found out long ago the advantages of the added velocity that they give.
Depending on the ranges you intend to reach out to is what length I would go with for the calibers you mentioned.
I would never go less then 30" on anything I shoot unless it was a factory rifle and i had no other choice.
I have carry guns in the 7/300 Weatherby and 7mm Mag that weigh 11# that have 30" barrels and the guns that I reach out with that are mainly stationary, have 34" to 37" barrels.
I have a 44" barrel standing by that I intend to make into a 300 RUM or Tomahawk this year. The velocity I should get from that one may be something to write home about.
It all depends on the range you want to reach out to, but none of my custom guns have less then 30" barrels.
Here is a list of some of them. You may be able to fit in your desire of a caliber from the ones I have.
7mm mag carry gun 30"
7/300 Weatherby Carry gun 30"
(5) 300 Weatherby LR hunting or 1000 yd competition guns for my wife and I-- 30"
300 Tomahawk --- 34"
As you can see, most are at least 30" but I prefer 34 to 37" barrels on my LR hunting guns in large 30 and 338 cal. configurations.
I would chose the 300 RUM with at least a 34" barrel out of the ones you mentioned for a longrange hunting cartridge.
If your wanting a 30 cal rifle for 1000 yard match shooting, the 300 Win mag or 300 Weathetby with at least a 30" barrel would be my choice.
Not only for the quick reply, (do you ever sleep?) but also for the ROUGH idea about how long to make it.
As I understand what you said, starting at 30 inches, add length based on case capacity. IE, 30-338 @ 30", 300 Win mag @ 32-34", and 300RUM @ 34-38". Is that somewhere in the ballpark?
Roughly, for every 5 to 10 grains of case capacity,add a couple of inches.
How long do they get before you block it?
The 30/338 or the 300 Win mag or the 300 RUM could all be 30" depending on what you want to do with any of these cartridges.
The 300 Win mag has more powder capacity then the 30/338 so it will give more velocity in the same length barrel. The 300 RUM has more powder capacity then the 300 Win mag and will give more velocity in the same length barrel if all are using the same bullet weight.
If you really want to increase the effectivness of the 300 RUM especially with 240 Gr Sierra MK bullets, I would go with a 34" to 36" barrel.
Usually blocks or sleeves are used when the barrel length goes over 32" or 34" depending on the diameter. If you have a tapored barrel of .950" (at the muzzle) or less, you may not need a block.
Most 1000 yd light Match guns with barrels of 30" don't have blocks. Some do but, not most.
Theres no set length of barrel for any particular cartridge. It's shooter preferance and how far he wants to reach out and touch something. If you want to send large high BC bullets in large overbore cases out to extreme range, get a longgggggg "Darryl Barrel."
During these winter evenings and mornings, I usually hit the forums to see what has been asked during the day or night. I do sleep, honest.
I order me a custome 300 RUM I opted for the 27" barrel.. but with reason.
1. I added a break which will put me at 28+"
2. Thats about all you can fit in a scabbard unless you go custom and them your talking $500+
3. Just had a good conversation with my gun smith about the 27" barrel. He has doen some testing with a few of the 300 RUMs he built.. He thinks I should be able to get 3000 fps from the 27" with the 200 or 220's
Just food for thought... I am in no way disputing what DC said.. just giving you ideas of what I had done..
I plan to hunt deer to 1200 yards with this rifle.
DC... curious to know the performance of the 30" barrel and the 308.....
That's not all the toys, plus I have a VERY good friend who is a gunsmith. I didn't mention I have been shooting since I was 12 yrs old and am now 62.
I have collected many rifles in those years and have shot many others that I no longer own.
Even my 22/284 that I didn't mention, has a 30" barrel.
I was trying to get the point across that there are many benifits to the additional barrel length beside additional velocity.
One of them is, you can set the barrel back when/if you run excessive rounds through the rifle and still give additional life to that same barrel. Additional velocity will give additional energy downrange too.
As per the length of a barrel with a muzzle brake attached. A muzzle brake adds NO benificial length to the bullet traveling down a barrel. As a matter of fact, when the bullet goes through a muzzle brake there must be clearance all around the bullet to make the brake work correctly. Some people add the brake as extra barrel length for bullet velocity, but that's not true. A 27" barrel is a 27" barrel even if a brake attached to it is 12" longer. [img]images/icons/smile.gif[/img]
As mentioned, there are times when the rifle must be shorter for carry purposes and this is understandable in your case with the horse scabbard.
The added velocity in my style of hunting warrents longer barrels because of the range we ususlly are shooting.
Like in other things, I think "longer" is "better." [img]images/icons/grin.gif[/img] and have seen the velocity increase at extended range in just about every cartridge that I have shot over the years.
If I can run a "240 Gr" bullet in a 34" barrel at 3235 FPS and a 220 gr at 3300FPS in the 300 RUM Imp (Tomahawk) and you are running a "220 gr" at 3000 FPS, I will take the additional velocity and remaining downrange energy, everytime. [img]images/icons/wink.gif[/img]
3025 to 3040 FPS is what I run the 220 gr in my match guns at Williamsport from my 300 Weatherbys with 30" barrels.
When LR Hunting, I want more velocity (to a degree)to fight the winds in the high ridges we hunt from. I still want to retain the accuracy also.
A person chambering a new barrel must decide;
1. What range he will be reaching out to when hunting.
2. Is the barrel going to be used for hunting or match shooting or both.
3. What caliber will be used with that barrel.
4. What length barrel can be used effectively when/if short range shooting with the same rifle, if one plans on doing that.
If I go short range hunting here in PA, I usually just grab my 280 Remington Mountain rifle and take a walk.
When walking in Colorado, I take the 7/300 Weatherby with the 30" barrel in case I catch one across a canyon.
When a person figures that for every 100 FPS of additional velocity the longer barrel will give, means a flatter shooting rifle by 12" to 20" (at least) at 1000 yards plus the added velocity also carries with it more retained energy [img]images/icons/smile.gif[/img].
Just thought I would point out the benifits of the longer barrels that I have found over the last 50 years.
Damn, I'm getting old [img]images/icons/shocked.gif[/img]
Hope we didn't confuse the original poster there in Wyoming.
Ric---As an add on here, the 308 Win I have is the Shilen DGA action and 30" Shilen barrel. I have not shot the rifle in about 4 yrs now and the last time I did was at Williamsport using the 175 Gr MK.
The 30" barrel gave me another 105 to 135 FPS over the other 308s I have owned over the years that had 24 and 26" barrels.
My powder of choice was 4064.
I see you have a 6.5-06 Improved, I am toying around with having one built for long range target shooting and some varmint shooting. I would like to use a Remington 700 action, I have one in blue but would prefer Stainless. I have access to shoot up to 1000 yards Upstate NY on private property. Do you have any comments or suggestions for that round (barrel length etc)? Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks for your time,
"A tie is as good as a loss, and no one remembers second place."