Having owned and shot both in the past and taken deer with 'em, I'd opt for the 7mmRemMag everytime. I don't even consider them in the same league.
I just like the 7Mag more. It's way cooler and seems to absolutely stomp the crap out of anything it encounters from 0-500yds.
Truth is; I really fell out of love with the .308 after owning a .300WinMag several years ago. Same bullet(s) but A LOT more authority!
I did a quick comparison using JBM Ballistics and Nolser #6 book specifics and a 10mph crosswind;
At 500yds, the .308 drops 30" and would drift 19.5". It arrives on-station in .627 seconds with 1425ft/lbs of energy.
At 500yds, the 7Mag drops 25" and would drift 15.3". It arrives on-station in .574 seconds with 1750ft/lbs of energy.
These are, of course, rudimentary figures but you get the idea. Both cartridges could do better with their respective deck stacked in their favor. I, however, do not feel the .308 would ever have an advantage over the 7Mag in anything other than felt recoil. IMO. JohnnyK.
"The only thing necessay for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing."
I'll second that. Even if your rifle has a standard 10 twist barrel, you can make the 7 mag even better. The 168 gr. Berger hunting VLD bullet has a G1 BC of .617. If your rifle doesn't shoot it well, the Classic Hunter is still .604. Between the speed you will see and those high BC's, your bullets will have significantly less wind drift than anything you can do with a .308.
My personal favorite caliber, if I could have only one for everything from prairie dogs to elk, is the 7 mag.
JW- the caliber is less important than the rifle. pick the rifle with a krieger barrel . or pick the one that shoots a 5 inch, 5 shot group at 500 yards. i do not have a 308. i do have 7 rm with a krieger barrel.
I have several of each caliber. It's hard to go wrong with either one.
My main deer rifle is a Browing A-Bolt Composite Stalker 7mm Rem Mag w/ BOSS. I bought one when I was 18, 8 years ago, but it got stolen in 2008, and I recently bought another one identical to it for hunting, since all my other rifles are heavy-barreled and bulky guns. The Browning is lightweight and I can carry it without noticing it being there so much, compared to the others.
Anyway, back to your question....I love the .308 caliber, and it is an EXCELLENT whitetail caliber for sub-500 yard shots. The trajectory is not as flat as the 7mm Mag, but it is just as capable and quite effective, if you get some nice handloads shooting some Nosler 165gr Accubonds. If you were shooting the Accubond 165gr's out of your 308, and sighting in at 100 yards, you'd be 13.8" low at 300, and 56.6" low at 500.
I prefer the 7mm Rem Mag b/c of it's very flat trajectory and how I can sight dead on at 100 yards, and only be about 10.7" low at 300 yards, and about 44.0" low at 500 yards. It tends to make shooting easier, especially if you don't carry a range finder with you.
It's not a huge variation in drop between the 2 inside of 500, but noticeable enough.
With that being said, if you want a flat-shooting lazer gun that is 100% perfect for whitetail hunting....Look into a Weatherby .257 Weatherby Mag.
Zero dope @ 100 yards, 8.0" low at 300, and only 34.9" low at 500.
I love my Mark-V Accumark .257 Wby Mag, and have taken several deer with it, using the Weatherby brand ammo, loaded with 110gr Nosler Accubonds. It ruins virtually no meat, with a tiny entrance and exit wound, but will totally wreck the lungs, heart, etc!
"I'm just a peckerwood who lives in the hills with too many guns..." - Bob Lee Swagger
"Give me a minute...I'm good. Give me an hour...I'm great. Give me 6 months...And I'm unbeatable." - Col. Hannibal Smith
Ignore everything I say, because I have a reading comprehension and memory problem...
Originally Posted by WildRose
The 284 is to the STW what a tricycle is to a Ninja.
Actually, I will chose between two specific Factory rifles. The Remington 700 Sendero in 7mag, or the CZ 550 Varmint Kevlar in .308. I have 3 other CZ 527's and they are awesome. I personally think they have the best out of the box factory trigger in the market. Also, every one I have is 1/2 MOA out of the box. Granted, they are small calibers and not a 550 model. Both the Rem and CZ have long heavy barrels, and both have Kevlar stocks with the aluminum bedding(two of my requirements). If I could get a CZ 550 in 7mag, that would be my choice. But its not available. Also, if I could get the Sendero in 25-06 or 264 Win mag(they used to make it) i'd pick that. That leads me to the two choices. I don't mean to say these are the two best rifles in this class, just the only two I will consider. Just personal preference. We shoot down long senderos usually out of a box blind. This is why weight is not an issue and actually provides for a more stable platform. The specific target is those big bucks that tend to always appear in the 300-400yd range.
JW/mudd- mudd i like your idea of an accumark .257. the guys i hunt with have not tried them. out here for coues , nice. JW- we have tried the senderos in many calibers i have had two 25-06s, my brother had a .264, i still have two 7 rm . i had a 7rsum sendero/vssf . those along with vssf in 308 can still be had by shopping. we also have a couple of the small caliber vssf also. enjoy. roninflag