270 wsm or 257 weatherby

Muley73 · #1 02-01-2010, 03:17 AM

I am looking for set up a new deer rifle. Would like it to be something I am comfortable with out to 800 yrds. Just looking for some input on what everyones thoughts are on these two calibers? I would probably be starting with a remington rifle and go from there.

Thanks,
Cody

johnnyk · #2 02-01-2010, 06:03 AM

Cody,
I have owned a 270WSM before and was impressed by its ballistics. The brass for the WSM will be cheaper than the Weatherby and more plentiful. Neither caliber have as much of a bullet selection as the 7mm or .30 cal, but Berger and Nosler (AccuBond) make good bullets for both the .257 and .277. In the right setup (trued action, 26-28" barrel, right load) the WSM will perform very similar to the 7mmRM. The .257 Weatherby is a dynamite cartridge in its own right, however. Given the same platform advantage, I feel it will holds it's own with cartridges up to 6.5-06, power and ballistics wise. Unless a faster twist barrel is spun on and the heavier (120+) pills, like the Wildcats, are used. All bets are off then. Tough decision. Have fun

JohnnyK.

liltank · #3 02-01-2010, 11:09 AM

My nod goes to the 270WSM. Berger makes a 150grn VLD with a BC of .531. It will be plenty of bullet to knock down a deer at 800yrds.

Tank

sniperjwt · #4 02-01-2010, 12:23 PM

i would go with the 257 weatherby. Although both are very capeable i like the 25 cal better than the 27 just a personal preferance

mike33 · #5 02-01-2010, 08:42 PM

+1 for the 257's. Mild recoil very deadly on deer.
mike

blipelt · #6 02-01-2010, 08:53 PM

Owned both I liked the 257 a little better, but like what was said more expensive to reload for. I have gotten rid of both and built a 7wsm since then. By far one of my favorite calibers. That is until it's big brother shows up in a couple of months.

Brent

bigngreen · #7 02-01-2010, 10:56 PM

I really like both the .25 and .270 cals for killing deer, one of my favorite is a 250AI and I would think the 257WBY would 300-400fps better. I also shoot a 270 WSM which will smoke them out there also, I am easily pushing the 110TTSX at 3670 fps, recoil is so mild it almost funny.
Running some ballistic cals, they are close but you can get the 270 WSM to do more with the wider range of bullets that will work for deer at longer range. The 110 TTSX will top out at 800 yrds but you can load 130 Bergers to 169.5 Wildcats for it also maybe giving you more wiggle room. You may have to be more careful with the 257 WBY bullet choices.
I would assume the 257WBY would be harder on barrels.
In short it's a toss up for me, but I prefer the 270WSM

The ideal solution is one of each!!!